Been to both, they have their pros/cons...i love them both and then again at the same time go ugh to both. We are all grown in my family. I do not mind the craziness, my lil sis on the other hand get a lil overwhelmed about it. I mean it is all about the experience right? Really both have good food, really i would say it is more about which characters you want to see, and if you have any other character meals in your trip, if mickey is important to see then do Chef Mickey's because you are guaranteed to see them, if it is important to see Cinderella do 1900 PF.