Best Seafood Signature Restaurant?

[AirGoofy]

I like Narcoosee's for the lobster and Fulton's for the King Crab Claws. We had a bad meal at FF the last time, so it will be awhile before we return.

[PoohsFan1]

My family loves Narcoossee's. The surf and turf is excellent, but after looking at the whole main lobster picture, I am thinking I am going to have to try that one next time . My family tried Fulton's for the first time this past September and had an excellent meal there as well. I had the King Crab Legs (my absolute favorite dish ever ) while both my DD11 and DH had the lobster and crab leg meal. DD11 was a little put off by the lobster because it didn't look like the lobster tail that she shared with me when we were dining at Narcoossee's....the one at fulton's still had the head, eyes, and tentacles. DH had to help her with it because she or I would not touch it . Once she was able to start eating the meat, she loved her meal...she has really become quite a lobster lover since this trip. As for my DD9, she is not that adventurous .

[tinacaplan]

I'd go for FF. We had an excellent meal there. Being from New England, Narcoosee's lobster doesn't impress me. The red snapper at FF, on the other hand... and my husband had scallops and crab cakes there, as well, and loved them.

[purple figment]

The people in our family really like the lobster at Narcoossee's and I've had the crabcakes which are also excellent.

A close second is the potato wrapped snapper at Flying Fish.

Also very good are the scallops at Cali Grill and the salmon at Artist's Point.

[Sweettears]

Originally Posted by tinacaplan

I'd go for FF. We had an excellent meal there. Being from New England, Narcoosee's lobster doesn't impress me. The red snapper at FF, on the other hand... and my husband had scallops and crab cakes there, as well, and loved them.

Been to the Cape at least 13 times. A fresh Maine lobster is a fresh Maine lobster. I have them several times a year in Illinois. What's the difference?