Confused- rent DVC or use discount? Difference? - The DIS Discussion Forums

Bookworm715 · 10-22-2012, 04:48 PM

I apologize,as this is probably an obvious question for most. I have searched and read so much, but it's just gotten me more confused on this topic.

We are going to WDW at the end of Jan or early Feb (we're flexible). Going by the discount that was recently released, and by the numbers David's DVC Rentals gives me, I see the following:

4 nights, Savannah view, at AKL (reserved online thru WDW): $1530
4 nights, studio Savannah view AK Villa (reserved thru David's): $728

What am I missing? It seems that I'm reading the room sizes are similar, and that we wouldn't get housekeeping if we rent the points...what possible reason would there be to do the direct reservation instead of the DVC? Surely I'm missing something, right?

softballmom3 · 10-22-2012, 04:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bookworm715

I apologize,as this is probably an obvious question for most. I have searched and read so much, but it's just gotten me more confused on this topic.

We are going to WDW at the end of Jan or early Feb (we're flexible). Going by the discount that was recently released, and by the numbers David's DVC Rentals gives me, I see the following:

4 nights, Savannah view, at AKL (reserved online thru WDW): $1530
4 nights, studio Savannah view AK Villa (reserved thru David's): $728

What am I missing? It seems that I'm reading the room sizes are similar, and that we wouldn't get housekeeping if we rent the points...what possible reason would there be to do the direct reservation instead of the DVC? Surely I'm missing something, right?

Nop you aren't missing anything

. I felt the same way when I found out about DVC. We are renting points for the first time next year and saved a huge chunk of $$$. I could care less about daily housekeeping so that wasn't a biggie for me at all!

MMS1125 · 10-22-2012, 05:02 PM

I agree renting points is a great $$ saver but you run the risk of not being eligible for any discounts that might come out otherwise. Granted for a Jan/Feb trip chances are you won't see anything better than the savings you would see for points. How many people are going? Studios are small there's only 1 bed and a pullout sofa. In a regular AKL room you get 2 beds.

With a rental you have to pay up front where as direct you can space your payments out or with room only pay when you arrive. You get daily housekeeping and peace of mind with a good cancellation policy than you don't get with a rental.

If you are firm on your dates and have all the funds up front renting is a great option IMO. Not sure how popular the savannah view studios are though it might be hard to get one for Jan/Feb at this point in time.

Bookworm715 · 10-22-2012, 05:07 PM

It'll be my husband and I and our two kids- 3 and 6. they will sometimes end up in the same twin bed, so I don't think space will be an issue in that sense. Also, we won't be spending much time in the room, so I think that would be ok. We might do a split reservation, maybe 3 days at AK and then pay for one night at Polynesian or something. We really are very flexible, as we've never stayed in a Disney property, so we'll be happy with just about anything we can get.

prairiesarah · 10-22-2012, 05:32 PM

You really won't find much difference room-wise and the price can't be beat going through David's. However the only issue you may find trying book through David's or renting through a DVC member is booking a room with that short of notice. From what I understand at any of the high demand resorts, you need to book 7 months out (I think the booking window is 7 months???). From what I understand it is fairly easy to get a room at SSR on shorter notice, but any of the others you may get lucky, but the chances are much slimmer.

sndral · 10-22-2012, 05:40 PM

Your studio will be on the 5th floor (unless concierge,) not prime viewing like eye level lower floors, but more panoramic - more looking down on the animals. I'm assuming that both units are @ Jambo, AKL has studios in Kidani as well.
The studio will have 1 bed and one sleeper sofa. You will need to pull out and re fold that sofa each day/night.
DVC units tend to cost more points on fri. and sat. nights, maybe your short stay avoids those nights?
Make sure your quoted cash room rate hasn't accidently added park tickets or insurance (the Disney site is weird that way.) Did you price out an AKL studio on a cash ressie w/ discount?
Generally the DVC rent studio v. room w/ discount comparisons seem to favor the rent DVC studio. Larger units sometimes the cash discount equals the rent DVC for the same unit, or is less.

butsy113 · 10-22-2012, 08:05 PM

If you want a AKV savannah view you should be able to get one no problem as long as you stay away from MLK weekend (I think the 19th and 20th). There are more studios over in Kidani Village. That would be your way to go. Also the savannah views will be better. If you want to see giraffes request the Sunset Savannah

Have a nice trip!

By the way, We love AKV!! That's why we call it "home"!

10-22-2012, 04:48 PM	#1
Bookworm715 Earning My Ears Join Date: Feb 2011 Posts: 8	Confused- rent DVC or use discount? Difference? I apologize,as this is probably an obvious question for most. I have searched and read so much, but it's just gotten me more confused on this topic. We are going to WDW at the end of Jan or early Feb (we're flexible). Going by the discount that was recently released, and by the numbers David's DVC Rentals gives me, I see the following: 4 nights, Savannah view, at AKL (reserved online thru WDW): $1530 4 nights, studio Savannah view AK Villa (reserved thru David's): $728 What am I missing? It seems that I'm reading the room sizes are similar, and that we wouldn't get housekeeping if we rent the points...what possible reason would there be to do the direct reservation instead of the DVC? Surely I'm missing something, right?

10-22-2012, 05:02 PM	#3
MMS1125 "You can design and create, and build the most wonderful place in the world. But it takes people to make the dream a reality." Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: 500 miles away from my happy place Posts: 968	I agree renting points is a great $$ saver but you run the risk of not being eligible for any discounts that might come out otherwise. Granted for a Jan/Feb trip chances are you won't see anything better than the savings you would see for points. How many people are going? Studios are small there's only 1 bed and a pullout sofa. In a regular AKL room you get 2 beds. With a rental you have to pay up front where as direct you can space your payments out or with room only pay when you arrive. You get daily housekeeping and peace of mind with a good cancellation policy than you don't get with a rental. If you are firm on your dates and have all the funds up front renting is a great option IMO. Not sure how popular the savannah view studios are though it might be hard to get one for Jan/Feb at this point in time. __________________ Fam of 5--addicted to Disney!

10-22-2012, 05:40 PM	#6
sndral DIS Veteran Join Date: Feb 2008 Posts: 1,250	Your studio will be on the 5th floor (unless concierge,) not prime viewing like eye level lower floors, but more panoramic - more looking down on the animals. I'm assuming that both units are @ Jambo, AKL has studios in Kidani as well. The studio will have 1 bed and one sleeper sofa. You will need to pull out and re fold that sofa each day/night. DVC units tend to cost more points on fri. and sat. nights, maybe your short stay avoids those nights? Make sure your quoted cash room rate hasn't accidently added park tickets or insurance (the Disney site is weird that way.) Did you price out an AKL studio on a cash ressie w/ discount? Generally the DVC rent studio v. room w/ discount comparisons seem to favor the rent DVC studio. Larger units sometimes the cash discount equals the rent DVC for the same unit, or is less. __________________

10-22-2012, 08:05 PM	#7
butsy113 Mouseketeer Join Date: Aug 2012 Location: Central Illinois Posts: 341	If you want a AKV savannah view you should be able to get one no problem as long as you stay away from MLK weekend (I think the 19th and 20th). There are more studios over in Kidani Village. That would be your way to go. Also the savannah views will be better. If you want to see giraffes request the Sunset Savannah Have a nice trip! By the way, We love AKV!! That's why we call it "home"! __________________ ME,DH,DS (10),DD (9)BUZ,TINKERBELL,MILO

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes	Rate This Thread
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode	Rate This Thread:

Sponsored Links
The DIS Register to remove Join Date: 1997 Location: Orlando, FL Posts: 1,000,000

10-22-2012, 05:07 PM	#4
Bookworm715 Earning My Ears Join Date: Feb 2011 Posts: 8	It'll be my husband and I and our two kids- 3 and 6. they will sometimes end up in the same twin bed, so I don't think space will be an issue in that sense. Also, we won't be spending much time in the room, so I think that would be ok. We might do a split reservation, maybe 3 days at AK and then pay for one night at Polynesian or something. We really are very flexible, as we've never stayed in a Disney property, so we'll be happy with just about anything we can get.

10-22-2012, 05:32 PM	#5
prairiesarah Earning My Ears Join Date: Jul 2012 Posts: 57	You really won't find much difference room-wise and the price can't be beat going through David's. However the only issue you may find trying book through David's or renting through a DVC member is booking a room with that short of notice. From what I understand at any of the high demand resorts, you need to book 7 months out (I think the booking window is 7 months???). From what I understand it is fairly easy to get a room at SSR on shorter notice, but any of the others you may get lucky, but the chances are much slimmer.