Pirate Cruise or Pirates League?

[wdwlovin'family]

We were wanting to surprise our boys with a few things this trip. I have been sold on the Pirate's cruise for a while now, but after reading the reviews, the pirates league sounds pretty fun too. My sons aren't horribly into pirates, but I thought the experience would be fun to surprise them with. They both seem to have their perks, and I like the two hours of adult time that could be had with the cruise. I know the cruise serves a lunch of sorts, but neither of my boys will eat an uncrustable. (one won't eat jelly and the other won't eat peanut butter -- go figure!) I thought I read somewhere that you can request a different meal and was also wondering if anyone has done that before. Lastly, if we did do the cruise, is any one better than the other? My first thought would be the Grand Floridian cruise but if there is a better one...

I can't make my reservations until Sept. 6th, but I like to plan ahead!

[briarbear]

We made ressie's for our kids so I would love to hear what others have to say. Maybe see some pics! If anyone knows what the dif. is between the ports I would love to hear that. They only had Port Orleans trip left. CM said GF was the popular one but didnt know why.
Bump