See if my logic checks out... - The DIS Discussion Forums

Mickey4me! · 08-30-2007, 12:39 PM

Last year during our Nov disney trip we purchased the dining plan, but due to the sudden death of my mother, our trip ended on day 2 and we really didn't get to experience the plan. In deciding whether we should purchase it this year, I first made all the ADRs that we wanted - LTT, CA Grill, BOMA breakfast and Ohana's. My daughter's boyfriend is traveling with us and is new to WDW so we wanted him to experience some of our favs. So, here's my logic

- cost of the DDP for 4 adults for 6 nights = $935.76
- cost of meals that we have ADRs for = $574.42 (inc. tax and tips)
- difference = $361.42

If you divide 361.42 by 4 that's 90.35 and if you divide 90.35 by 6days you've got $15/day per person. So the question is - will four adults each spend more or less than $15 a day on breakfast/lunch and a snack each day and dinner for 3 of the six nights (the other 3 are in the ADR total)?

Even though we're staying in a 2 bedroom villa, my thoughts are that we will spend slightly more than that so, DDP would be a good deal.

Does that make sense to everyone or am I missing something?

hollieplus2 · 08-30-2007, 05:00 PM

Did you factor in the counter service you get to use also? That would cover breakfast or lunch each day. Also, a lot of people share a counter service meal since it's a lot of food. If you guys could do it you could use 2 CS for breakfast and 2 CS for lunch and still have all your TS for dinner plus a snack to use.

MOM POPPINS · 08-30-2007, 05:03 PM

First sorry to hear about your Mom, my Mom died recently as well. I really miss her!

Now to try and answer your question. You would def. spend at least the 15 a day for each person on lunch/breakfast and a snack. You also mention that you would also have to plan 3 more meals. I think the dining plan is a great option for you.

I also looked at your totals and 542 seems low for 6 dinners TS. I know we have a big family but our table service is usually at least 200 a night.

Happy Planning! I would go with the DDP!

Mickey4me! · 09-01-2007, 06:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MOM POPPINS

I also looked at your totals and 542 seems low for 6 dinners TS. I know we have a big family but our table service is usually at least 200 a night.
Happy Planning! I would go with the DDP!

Actually the $542 was only for 4 ADRs I made so I definitely think we'll spend at least another $350+ on lunches, snacks and a couple more dinners. Just wanted to make sure I wasn't overlooking something. Thanks for your help!

lowie · 09-01-2007, 07:09 PM

you also overlooked the tax and tips! if you are eaters (not only big eaters) then the plan will work out. you'll get to try so many things and not skimp on your choices.

08-30-2007, 12:39 PM	#1
Mickey4me! Lost my screen name so I'm starting from scratch! Join Date: Aug 2005 Location: Kill Devil Hills, NC Posts: 353	See if my logic checks out... Last year during our Nov disney trip we purchased the dining plan, but due to the sudden death of my mother, our trip ended on day 2 and we really didn't get to experience the plan. In deciding whether we should purchase it this year, I first made all the ADRs that we wanted - LTT, CA Grill, BOMA breakfast and Ohana's. My daughter's boyfriend is traveling with us and is new to WDW so we wanted him to experience some of our favs. So, here's my logic - cost of the DDP for 4 adults for 6 nights = $935.76 - cost of meals that we have ADRs for = $574.42 (inc. tax and tips) - difference = $361.42 If you divide 361.42 by 4 that's 90.35 and if you divide 90.35 by 6days you've got $15/day per person. So the question is - will four adults each spend more or less than $15 a day on breakfast/lunch and a snack each day and dinner for 3 of the six nights (the other 3 are in the ADR total)? Even though we're staying in a 2 bedroom villa, my thoughts are that we will spend slightly more than that so, DDP would be a good deal. Does that make sense to everyone or am I missing something? __________________ CBR - Dec 95, BW/DCL - Oct 98,HHI - June 99,OKW - Dec 00, DCL/Vero - July 02, BWV - Jan 03, OKW - Nov 03, YC - Oct 04, WLV - Nov 04, BWV - Nov 05, BCV - Jan 06, SS - Nov 06, OKW - Nov 07, HHI - Jan 09 DCL - Oct 09 DCL - Dec 10, AKL - Nov 10, DCL & OKW - Oct 11, DCL & BWV - Feb 13 Our Magical 10.17 Trip Report

08-30-2007, 05:00 PM	#2
hollieplus2 Tags always make people happy I kept saying chewable My toes might appreciate some alone time Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: Not close enough Posts: 1,323	Did you factor in the counter service you get to use also? That would cover breakfast or lunch each day. Also, a lot of people share a counter service meal since it's a lot of food. If you guys could do it you could use 2 CS for breakfast and 2 CS for lunch and still have all your TS for dinner plus a snack to use. __________________ DH ME DS July 2006---Pop, ASMovies, Animal Kingdom September/October 2007---POFQ December 2009---WDW & DCL September 2012---POR/ToT 10 Miler

08-30-2007, 05:03 PM	#3
MOM POPPINS I keep getting SOUVENIRS (wink) when I go to WDW! Join Date: Aug 2000 Location: Trenton, Texas Posts: 3,483	First sorry to hear about your Mom, my Mom died recently as well. I really miss her! Now to try and answer your question. You would def. spend at least the 15 a day for each person on lunch/breakfast and a snack. You also mention that you would also have to plan 3 more meals. I think the dining plan is a great option for you. I also looked at your totals and 542 seems low for 6 dinners TS. I know we have a big family but our table service is usually at least 200 a night. Happy Planning! I would go with the DDP! __________________ Me DH DD23 DD18 DD15 DD11 DS9 2000 Dixie Landing HIFS '01 Contemporary/Dolphin 2 Trips '02 Dolphin '03 Dolphin '04 BWV/WLV '05 BWV/BCV 2 Trips '06 BWV/Dolphin/Saratoga/OKW 3 Trips '07 BWV/SSR 2 trips '08 BWV May/November '09 BWV March/May/Nov 2010 20th. POR AKL Villa's May 2011BWV September 2011 BWV January 2012 AKL Villa's May 2012 Saratoga Springs December 2012 May 2013 AKL

09-01-2007, 07:09 PM	#5
lowie DIS Veteran I got a tootsie pop with no tootsie Join Date: Feb 2006 Location: Palm Beach, FL. Posts: 2,179	you also overlooked the tax and tips! if you are eaters (not only big eaters) then the plan will work out. you'll get to try so many things and not skimp on your choices. __________________ Lori (me) Michael (dh) Jordana (dd16) Jason (ds11) And, by the way, I adore you... in frightening and dangerous ways.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes	Rate This Thread
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode	Rate This Thread:

Sponsored Links
The DIS Register to remove Join Date: 1997 Location: Orlando, FL Posts: 1,000,000