The DIS Discussion Forums - DISboards.com Disney the segway and the ADA
 Find Hotel Specials & DIScounts Disney World Universal Orlando Disneyland Other
 Register Chat FAQ Tickers Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

03-04-2006, 10:49 AM   #106
Gwinfred
Earning My Ears

Join Date: Mar 2006
Posts: 50

Quote:
 Originally Posted by Chuck S Well, it is certainly common sense to know that being hit with a metal object traveling at 6mph will do less damage than being hit with a metal object traveling at 12 mph. The Segways weight is appoximately the same as an ECV. If you are hit with an ECV traveling 6 mph you would sustain less damage than an ECV traveling at 12 mph. Simple physics. That weight, along with the weight of the rider, is also distibuted between two points of contact with the ground, vs 3 or 4 with an ECV or wheelchair. Making each contact point bear a heavier load if it runs over a foot. Again, simple physics.

You keep editing your post but you're not answering my questions from below.

 03-04-2006, 10:55 AM #107 Chuck S DVC Boards Co-Moderator     Join Date: Feb 2000 Location: Seguin, Texas USA Posts: 25,969 If a Segway strikes an object or human at full speed, it can not stop immediately. An object in motion tends to stay in motion. Segways and their riders at full speed have momentum, there is no way for momentum to vanish in to thin air. If the Segway, traveling at 12mph, were to strike a solid object and suddenly stop the rider would most likely be ejected, as the rider would also be traveling at 12 mph. Just like objects in a car continue moving forward after a crash. __________________ DVC Member at OKW since 1992
|
The DIS
Register to remove

Join Date: 1997
Location: Orlando, FL
Posts: 1,000,000
 03-04-2006, 10:56 AM #108 Chuck S DVC Boards Co-Moderator     Join Date: Feb 2000 Location: Seguin, Texas USA Posts: 25,969 I edit my posts for spelling, and to add a thought. You simply reply at the same time. __________________ DVC Member at OKW since 1992
03-04-2006, 10:59 AM   #109
Gwinfred
Earning My Ears

Join Date: Mar 2006
Posts: 50

Quote:
 Originally Posted by Chuck S If a Segway strikes an object or human at full speed, it can not stop immediately. An object in motion tends to stay in motion. Segways and their riders at full speed have momentum, there is no way for momentum to vanish in to thin air. If the Segway, traveling at 12mph, were to strike a solid object and suddenly stop the rider would most likely be ejected, as the rider would also be traveling at 12 mph. Just like objects in a car continue moving forward after a crash.
that is absolutely correct, however

If the Segway were to strike someone or something the power to propel it forward would cease.

If a power wheelchair or an ECV were to strike something or someone the power to propel it forward would continue until removed by the operator.

03-04-2006, 11:01 AM   #110
Chuck S
DVC Boards Co-Moderator

Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Seguin, Texas USA
Posts: 25,969

Quote:
 Originally Posted by Gwinfred It would be common sense (although not necessarily true) to conclude that being hit with the same object would do more damage at 12 mph versus 6 mph. But we are talking about different objects. A 350 pound power wheelchair for example which continues to move even after striking someone and can break toes and legs when striking them. Versus a 84 pound device which stops immediately upon contact with another and has been demonstrated to cause no injury when rolling over anothers fingers. There is no common sense in comparing apples with oranges.
Comapring apples to oranges...the weight of a manned power wheelchair to a riderless Segway?
__________________

DVC Member at OKW since 1992

 03-04-2006, 11:02 AM #111 Gwinfred Earning My Ears   Join Date: Mar 2006 Posts: 50 But I do enjoy the debate :-)
03-04-2006, 11:03 AM   #112
Gwinfred
Earning My Ears

Join Date: Mar 2006
Posts: 50

Quote:
 Originally Posted by Chuck S Comapring apples to oranges...the weight of a manned power wheelchair to a riderless Segway?

Not at all, there are many power chairs out there that weigh more than 300 pounds.

 03-04-2006, 11:06 AM #113 Chuck S DVC Boards Co-Moderator     Join Date: Feb 2000 Location: Seguin, Texas USA Posts: 25,969 And there are many ECVs that weigh the same or less than a Segway. __________________ DVC Member at OKW since 1992
 03-04-2006, 11:14 AM #114 Gwinfred Earning My Ears   Join Date: Mar 2006 Posts: 50 Well that may be true but that's not the debate. For instance the Bounder Plus wheelchair can hold users up to 500 pounds and can travel at 11.6 mph. So the chair weighs over 300 pounds and with a 500 pound rider that would be 800 pounds coming at you 11.6 mph. Completely permissible for use at Disney. So how do you like those odds in comparison to someone on a Segway?
 03-04-2006, 11:18 AM #115 Chuck S DVC Boards Co-Moderator     Join Date: Feb 2000 Location: Seguin, Texas USA Posts: 25,969 How many of those mega-chairs would you see in comparison to the number of folks on a Segway? And how many would you see being used for joyriding as compared to Segways? We aren't talking about unqualified/untrained drivers. We're talking about a way for Disney to legally tell the difference. __________________ DVC Member at OKW since 1992
 03-04-2006, 11:27 AM #116 Gwinfred Earning My Ears   Join Date: Mar 2006 Posts: 50 Well that's a good question, but with the American obesity problem and more people using the sit down scooters as opposed to stand up devices like the Segway for mobility we will unfortunately probably see more of these mega-chairs than Segways in the future. I've found most people to be lazy, lazy people don't use Segways they use scooters, even though the Segway is a healthier proposition for them, standing is work. and by the way I am not implying that all people who use scooters are lazy. scooters are a very valuable mobility tool, they are affordable and effective particularly for those where finance or standing is an issue. and there are plenty of people who can stand but have mobility problems that shouldn't use a Segway. (In my opinion)
 03-04-2006, 01:17 PM #117 fredkap Earning My Ears   Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: Los Angeles Posts: 28 Chuck, Iam glad that we are in agreement that disabled Segway users that will use their Segway in a safe manner are entitled to use their Segway in a Disney park and that the problem is how to keep out non-disabled "joy-riders." You feel that there should be a certification process. I have a drivers license not a certification. Neither my driving school instructor (going back quite a number of years) nor the State want to be liable for "certifying" that I am a good driver. If Disney were to test Segway users or have them go through their class, could they not be liable for incomplete or poor instruction if someone did something unfortunate after going through their test or class? An organization such as draft (Disabled Rights Advocates for Technology) would also be opening itself up to litigation if it tried to determine who is a qualified disabled person and who isn't. The answer is what is done with all other disabled individuals and service animals etc which is that you ask and rely on the answer. BTW It appears to be illegal to require a disabled individual to prove that they have insurance. A surprisingly high percentage of Segway owners have insurance. My policy with Progressive costs me \$120 and covers both theft and \$250,000 worth of liability insurance.
 03-04-2006, 01:47 PM #118 Chuck S DVC Boards Co-Moderator     Join Date: Feb 2000 Location: Seguin, Texas USA Posts: 25,969 But the state of CA did give you a drivers license based on the fact that you exibited competency behind the wheel of your car...you had to pass a test. A rose by any other name. Simply because you would carry a certificate that you passed and completed a Segway safety course would not make the state liable any more than they are liable if you have an auto accident. Actually, I think insurance is also a great idea, I didn't know they'd write a policy for Segway use. I wonder why it is illegal to require folks to show proof of insurance or self-insurance to use it in public places...we have to in order to get a car license & tags. Unless Segway theft is a poblem, insurance rates could be highly discounted for those that complete a safety course. There are a lot of changes that could be made to the ADA to make it both more protective for the disabled and easier for public venues to determine who is and is not using a device for medical/mobility issues. As another poster said, service animals in training have to be identified with special vests. Most service animals also have special harnesses and grip handles, easiliy identifying them as a trained service animal when they are "on duty." It is pretty easy to tell an "in service" animal from a family pet. __________________ DVC Member at OKW since 1992
03-04-2006, 02:05 PM   #119
Gwinfred
Earning My Ears

Join Date: Mar 2006
Posts: 50

Quote:
 Originally Posted by Chuck S I wonder why it is illegal to require folks to show proof of insurance or self-insurance to use it in public places...we have to in order to get a car license & tags. As another poster said, service animals in training have to be identified with special vests. Most service animals also have special harnesses and grip handles, easiliy identifying them as a trained service animal when they are "on duty." It is pretty easy to tell an "in service" animal from a family pet.

I think that one of the reasons that proof of insurance is prohibited for people with disabilities is that when you're using an assistive device that device whether it's a wheelchair or a scooter or a Segway allows you to do things that those without a mobility related disabilities do.

Since we don't require individuals to be insured to walk through the park then there shouldn't be a requirement for people with disabilities to be insured to roll through the park.

With regard to service animals in training, there is absolutely no protection under the ADA for service animals in training, with or without a vest. Service animals are protected, those in training are not. To be sure most of them are accommodated but you can't transport them on an airline unless the airline agrees to allow it to with or without a vest.

And while you are correct that the presence of harnesses and grips are helpful in identifying service animals they like vests are not required and indeed many service animals perform other functions for people with disabilities including opening doors, retrieving items, even dressing them.

So it's not so easy to tell when you see a monkey setting on the shoulder of a guy in a wheelchair.

 Thread Tools Display Modes Rate This Thread Linear Mode Rate This Thread: 5 : Excellent 4 : Good 3 : Average 2 : Bad 1 : Terrible

 Posting Rules You may not post new threads You may not post replies You may not post attachments You may not edit your posts BB code is On Smilies are On [IMG] code is On HTML code is Off Forum Rules
 Forum Jump User Control Panel Private Messages Subscriptions Who's Online Search Forums Forums Home Disney Trip Planning Forums     Welcome to the DIS     The DIS Unplugged Podcast         Power of 10 - DIS Events to Benefit GKTW         Podcast Cruises         DIS Adventures by Disney Trips     Theme Parks Attractions and Strategies         Doing the Happy Dance!         Disney Promotions and Celebrations--Current Promotion: Limited Time Magic         Theme Parks Community     Disney Resorts         Disney Discount Codes and Rates         Countdowns and Live Reports         Resort Community Threads & Photo-Video     Disney Restaurants         Disney Dining Reservations         Disney Dining Plan         Disney Dining Reviews     Orlando Hotels and Attractions         Hotel & Accommodations Reviews     Adventures By Disney     Disney Trip Reports         Pre-Trip Reports and Plans         Completed Trip Reports     Budget Board     Disney Rumors and News     Disney for Families         DIS Dads     Disney for Adults and Solo Travelers     The College Board     Teen Disney         Teen Board Birthdays and Celebrations     Gay and Lesbian at Disney     Disney World Tips     Transportation     disABILITIES!         disABILITIES Community Board     Camping at Disney World         Camping Community Board     Disney Weddings and Honeymoons         Planning our Happily Ever After             Completed trip reports and planning journals     DIS en Español Disney Vacation Club     Purchasing DVC     DVC Member Services     DVC Resorts     DVC-Mousecellaneous     DVC Trip Reports Global Neighbours     UK Trip Planning Forum     UK Community Board     UK DVC Discussion     UK Trip Reports Board     Canadian Trip Planning & Community Board     Disneyland Paris Trip Planning & Community Board         Disneyland Paris Trip Reports Board     Other Lands         Australia         Tokyo Disneyland         Hong Kong Disneyland Disney Cruise Line     Disney Cruise Line Forum         Disney Cruise Meets         Disney Cruise Line Trip Reports             Disney Cruise Line Pre-Trip Reports Royal Caribbean     Royal Caribbean Disneyland     Disneyland (California)         Southern California Theme Parks         Disneyland Community Board     California & the West         Southern California         Las Vegas     Disneyland Trip Reports         California & the West Trip Reports Universal Studios/Sea World     Universal Studios/Islands of Adventure Forums     Universal Orlando Resorts & Hotels     Universal Studios Trip Reports     Sea World / Discovery Cove Just for Fun     Community Board         Congratulations & Birthday Wishes         Games         Exchanges         United We Stand     Disney Movies, Books, TV and Music     Photography Board     Disney Online Games         Non-Disney Online Games         Virtual Traders Market         Online Gaming Community Board         Virtual Magic Kingdom (VMK) Museum             VMK Creations     In Memoriam     Dis Meets     The Creative Community         Arts and Crafts         Cooking         Flower & Garden Forum         Home Interior         Virtual Scrapbook         Scrapbooking         Swaps     W.I.S.H         Eating Healthy         Events/Competition         WISH Journals     Coping and Compassion     Just Say Thanks     Disney Rewards Programs     Disney Collectors Board         Trades/Wants Board     Creative DISigns     Disney Cast Members Technical Support     Technical Support         Test Board

 GET OUR DIS UPDATES DELIVERED BY EMAIL

 -- Default ---- DIS Unplugged ---- Disneyland ---- Disney Cruise Line ---- Universal Orlando ---- Disney Vacation Club ---- FLTOURS Transportation ---- Swan & Dolphin Resort ---- Adventures by Disney ---- Holidays ------ Holidays Light Contact Us - www.DISboards.com - Archive - Privacy Statement - Top

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:51 AM.