Honestly, I think it depends. I did the poll and said UPGRADE, as that was my initial reaction, but the more I've thought about it, I don't know! We've stayed at all levels and there are great things about each. This year we're going to be staying at AoA only because my son is 4 and is obsessed with Cars. I was going back and forth, and I realize that a Cars suite may not be a 'value' and I'm giving up a few things, but for my family right now, AoA is what I feel is the best fit for us. So before I can answer, I need to know more about your family! Are you staying at ASMo because your son loves Buzz Lightyear? No, don't upgrade. Are the kids a little older and would like a nicer pool and maybe a TS restaurant, then yes!
Jenn, DH, DS19, DS5