Another "Which Would You Rather" post: SOG, CSR or AoA

[iheartdisney]

Long story short... Planning a trip this summer, and I have been appointed the head planner. lol
Our party will consist of Me, DD10, DS9, and DD7, plus my best friend from 4 duty stations ago, her husband and DD10. The last time we saw each other was in 2008.
I've been to WDW more times than i can count, they have never been. I usually stay All Star, with a few stays at SOG.
So, they say I'm in charge, no preference. The three options I've come up with thus far are Shades of Green, AoA Little Mermaid Standard room, or Coronado Springs. Priced them out yesterday using the military discount, adding the dining plan.
I LOVE Shades of Green, but hate the dining options there. bleh. Plus, no dining plan. I'd really like to have everything paid before we get there.
I'm kind of leaning towards CSR, because it is around $200 more for the 6 night stay. Our last visit, we stayed at the Fort Wilderness Cabins, and I have to admit... I kind of liked the quiet (it was very different than the usual atmosphere at the All Stars)
I did look into AoA because, well, it is new. And since it is their daughter's first trip, maybe she would like the over-the-top theme.
So I am asking for DIS opinions! Which would you rather, all things considered?

[FantasiaMagic]

I think CS becuase since its a mod it does have more amenities then a value. I hear it has a great pool with a great slide also. I have never stayed (only at SoG out of your choices) and I agree SoG food choice were not the best...