The DIS Discussion Forums -

The DIS Discussion Forums - (
-   Disney Resorts (
-   -   Did I make a mistake? (

BrdwayBoy 03-08-2013 08:16 PM

Did I make a mistake?
I've booked a week long stay at the Polynesian for the end of August. I've always wanted to stay here, but after reading some reports about the less-than-stellar conditions of the resort and I'm hoping that I haven't made a mistake.
I know they are in the midst of refurbishing the Longhouses...


RunningWithScissors 03-08-2013 08:42 PM

Heaven's no! The last refurb they did was a while ago, but the rooms are still very, very nice. It could be a little messy, but we stayed there during the last refurb and had no issues. The Poly is AMAZING! Check Tikiman's site and keep updated on the progress and request a room in a longhouse that has finished the refurb! I'm so jealous!! Poly is a favorite of ours!!

scjo68 03-08-2013 08:51 PM

We love the Poly.
We have stayed there twice, and have not had any problems.
The decor appeals to us, but it may not be to everyone's taste.
It is not what I would call over-the-top luxury or elegance. So if you are looking for that then the Poly may not be your "cup of tea".

I cannot comment on the refurbishments, as we stayed there over a year ago. But if I could get the same kind of rate we got then, I would book there again.

mmmears 03-08-2013 09:06 PM

We booked the Poly for the first time several years ago, then kept second-guessing the choice based on some reviews. Well, we really enjoyed our time there. So if you've visited and like the place (or looked at lots of photos online) then I wouldn't be too worried. Not everyone likes the Poly -- but I think it's a great resort and it has very good options for transportation.

If you are concerned about the rooms you can always request a renovated one... some of the longhouses should be done by August. :goodvibes

BrdwayBoy 03-09-2013 01:48 AM

Thank you for all of the replies. I stayed at AKL last year, and completely fell in love with. I'm going to do my best stop thinking about what I've read, and just enjoy my trip.


Cindie-rella 03-09-2013 01:50 AM

Here is the refurb schedule from Tikiman's site.
Now the schedule for start dates as it was presented (assume about 2 months approx. for completion):

Hawaii January 6
Samoa February 3
Niue/ Rarotonga March 3
Tokelau March 31
Aotearoa April 21
Tonga (lounge only but will be closed) May 5
Fiji May 19
Tuvalu June 16
Tahiti July 14
Rapa Nui August 11

I think it's fair to assume you'll end up in a completely refurbed room :thumbsup2 I'm staying at the POLY for my 1st time next month and most likely will NOT be in a new room, but I don't mind...from what I seem to be finding out, this resort as a whole is awesome and relaxing and has great restaurants and transportation and enables you to watch Wishes from your room (TPV/LV) or beach...what more could we ask for, right ? Relax, I think we are going to be "hooked" after our 1st POLY experience ! I cannot wait ! :goodvibes

mickeynut1 03-09-2013 08:59 AM

Not every resort suits everyone's tastes, but you will never know if the Poly is for you unless you try it for yourself. With that said, after just one stay there, it is now our favorite resort. I had the same reservations after booking the Poly. I read many not-so-good reviews and started second guessing our choice and considered changing resorts. After giving it alot of thought, I decided to stick with it as the Poly was the one resort we always said that one day we will give it a try. We fell in the love with the resort the minute we checked in. We had a magical stay and loved everything about the Poly from the large rooms, the pool, the beach, Captain Cooks, etc. We have tried other resorts since our Poly stay (and have loved them all), but the Poly will always be our favorite and our #1 choice. Take the reviews with a grain of salt and give the Poly a really is a fabulous resort.

toodycat 03-09-2013 10:51 AM

I am not a huge Poly booster, but it looks like you'll be there when the majority of the rooms are brand spanking new. Also at the end of August, rooms cost less and the parks are less crowded, so it is a good time to try a new resort. You won't be paying top dollar or struggling to get through holiday crowds. The Poly has very large rooms and the best transportation, so those two factors alone will make your trip more magical. Have a great time.

fivedisfans 03-09-2013 02:21 PM

I don't think you'll regret it! We stayed at Poly for the first time last August and have now sworn that we'll never stay anywhere else! Location is excellent, grounds are beautiful, and our room was stunningly sparkling clean (and I am notoriously picky about hotel cleanliness). The ability to get Dole Whips any time is an added little bonus. :)

davedmaine 03-09-2013 03:03 PM


Originally Posted by BrdwayBoy (Post 47743454)
I've booked a week long stay at the Polynesian for the end of August. I've always wanted to stay here, but after reading some reports about the less-than-stellar conditions of the resort and I'm hoping that I haven't made a mistake.
I know they are in the midst of refurbishing the Longhouses...


Do yourself a favor and check out the reviews on Trip Advisor for the most objective. You're only going to get Poly fanatics on this board..

Pier60 03-09-2013 03:47 PM

We haved stayed AKL and Poly and found them to be similiar although being on the monorail line truimphs it for Poly. Loved them both!

heidijanesmith 03-09-2013 04:15 PM

We LOVED the Poly and would recommend staying there.

1-The rooms are huge, day bed in every room and plenty of bathroom space
2-great location. Easy monorail access to MK or quick boat ride. Easy walk to TTC to catch EPCOT monorail. Good bus service to other locations-shares with GF and or CR, but does not take very long
3-Beautiful landscaping and theme. The Poly is beautiful and worth spending time just checking out the grounds
4-Great food options, on site. 24 hour Captain cooks, Ohana and Kona
5-Wishes from the beach, CGH or the pool. DH does not like to watch Wishes with the huge crowds at MK, but found watching Wishes at the Poly to be a pleasure.

1-small pool for the size of the resort. The main Volcano pool is small and can get crowded. We liked the quiet pool better
2-design flaw with fridges. Even keeping the door to the fridge cabinet, our fridge would not keep our items cold enough. Luckily we brought two collapsible coolers with us.

August heat is brutal, taking a break during the most crowded and hottest part of the day is crucial. Staying at the Poly makes a mid-day break very easy. The Tikiman website has great maps of the property, longhouses and transportation times.

shopgirl78 03-09-2013 04:21 PM

We loved, loved, loved the Poly. The pool is amazing!

toonaspie 03-09-2013 10:31 PM

I wish I could afford to stay at the Polynesian. I say if this is your first time there, give it a chance and see how well it goes. One of the big plusses of the Poly is that the rooms are bigger compared to other deluxes. Room conditions are always a catch-22 regardless of what resort you end up staying at.

clapton 03-10-2013 12:14 AM

Stayed at the Poly years ago. Always felt that it was outdated and worn looking.For the price I would rather stay at WL or BC . But everyone has their own favorites and opinions. So if you really want to try it that's what you should do. I'm sure you'll have a great time. After all your in Disney!

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:09 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.

Copyright 1997-2014, Werner Technologies, LLC. All Rights Reserved.