The DIS Discussion Forums - DISboards.com

The DIS Discussion Forums - DISboards.com (http://www.disboards.com/index.php)
-   Disney Dining Plan (http://www.disboards.com/forumdisplay.php?f=116)
-   -   Is DxDP worth it anymore? (http://www.disboards.com/showthread.php?t=3021332)

cookieswithangel 11-14-2012 10:28 AM

Is DxDP worth it anymore?
 
So my party has used the DxDP the last two vacations. We first got the DxDP on free dining and upgraded. We fell in love. We then agreed that we would pay the $75 a person a night this year because it was vacation, and we wanted the luxury of not having to worry about the prices because we already paid for it.
Now, with prices at around $100 a person a night for 2013, I'm really questioning if the dining plan has any value for us. We tend to eat three meals a day, often 1 CS and 2 TS, and indulge in the apps and desserts. Some signatures like California Grill and Jiko, and character breakfasts like Tusker House and Crystal Palace. Our trip length would be 2 weeks. And $1400 a person, well, I'm not so easily jumping on the DxDP train.

A note: I doubt we'd go down to the regular DDP, because we really do love appetizers, and we are the "we have to eat breakfast" type of people.

Any advice? We're really hoping for free dining, but if that doesn't happen, would you go with the DxDP, or deal with OOP? Thanks in advance!

aaarcher86 11-14-2012 10:41 AM

I think it just depends. It's definitely removed a lot of frequent users with the price increase.

We added S/P/D which makes the cost go down a bit since we can upgrade from the DDP offered at a moderate.

I priced it out before at full price vs. what we'd pay out of pocket and we still came out about $200 under OOP with the DXDP.

Even if we came out even or $100 more or so, I'd probably still go for it with the added apps and deserts and such just for the treat on vacation.

I'd definitely do a price comparison with the menus from allears.net. I'm going to do another one when I have time just to make sure it's worth it and to avoid any calculations I might have missed, but I can't see us taking it off. The regular DDP doesn't give us enough TS credits that we need (I know we could pay out of pocket for the rest, but I don't feel like the hassle lol).

Colleen27 11-14-2012 04:42 PM

For us, no. Not any more. If we were all actual adults with adult sized appetites, maybe, but we have a "junior" (DD11) who doesn't even come close to eating adult portions and often travel with my mom who also has a light appetite. At the current pricing, the appetizers we'd share and desserts that we'd skip and credits we'd use for quick service suck the value out of the plan. Since I'll have an AP for the next few trips the TiW was a clear-cut winner over the DxDDP but even without it we'd likely go OOP.

I'd still use the plan if we were going during free dining and only paying the upgrade cost but at "rack rate" it isn't worthwhile for us any more.

inkedupmomma 11-14-2012 06:11 PM

I'm exactly like you! Same reasons for DxDp. With that said, no. I would not pay regular rates for it. Only use it if discounted, otherwise its no savings to us. I would skip any DP at all and put that money away, this way its just like your own ddp!

cookieswithangel 11-14-2012 09:12 PM

Thanks for the feedback! I guess the only real way to see if its even possibly worth it would be to price out everything. (that's where 14 nights is a bit of a pain to figure out all those meals!)
I really do hope they offer FD to make the DxDP a no-brainer for us, but for now I guess we'll just have to think about what all we would eat and if that's valued at $100 per person/night.

inkedupmomma 11-14-2012 09:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cookieswithangel (Post 46711306)
Thanks for the feedback! I guess the only real way to see if its even possibly worth it would be to price out everything. (that's where 14 nights is a bit of a pain to figure out all those meals!)
I really do hope they offer FD to make the DxDP a no-brainer for us, but for now I guess we'll just have to think about what all we would eat and if that's valued at $100 per person/night.

I did that 2 week math for our trip last year... and with our FD it was NOT worth it then either! The discount is the only real way to make it worthy anymore :/

davedmaine 11-15-2012 07:04 AM

Not with kids in the party. And not because of the portion sizes/what they can eat, etc., but it seems to be cruel to me because with that plan you're basically a slave to your ADRs every day. After you finish one meal, you pretty much have to start thinking about getting to your next one. I'd rather let the kids have fun in the parks and stick to one TS a day..

aaarcher86 11-15-2012 08:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by davedmaine (Post 46712861)
Not with kids in the party. And not because of the portion sizes/what they can eat, etc., but it seems to be cruel to me because with that plan you're basically a slave to your ADRs every day. After you finish one meal, you pretty much have to start thinking about getting to your next one. I'd rather let the kids have fun in the parks and stick to one TS a day..

I'll never understand why people say this ^^^.

We do the DXDDP. We eat an early sit down breakfast and a sit down dinner. We have the entire day in between to run around, ride rides, meet characters, watch shows, etc. We also chop off a ton of time that other people wait in line since we get to meet a ton of characters while we eat.

Eating breakfast at 7:30a or 8a and eating dinner at 7;30p hardly leaves us rushing to our next ADR.

THOSE POOR, TORTURED CHILDREN! :lmao:

sheilanne 11-15-2012 10:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by aaarcher86

I'll never understand why people say this ^^^.

We do the DXDDP. We eat an early sit down breakfast and a sit down dinner. We have the entire day in between to run around, ride rides, meet characters, watch shows, etc. We also chop off a ton of time that other people wait in line since we get to meet a ton of characters while we eat.

Eating breakfast at 7:30a or 8a and eating dinner at 7;30p hardly leaves us rushing to our next ADR.

THOSE POOR, TORTURED CHILDREN! :lmao:

This is exactly why my family uses DXDP. We do early character bkfst and signature dinner. This is perfect for us and use snacks for lunch. Our trip is in 2 weeks and weren't lucky enough for free ding at BLT, but crunched the numbers and still the best option for my family. Hated paying rack rates but just the best fit. If families are used to fast food and actually prefer it the dining plan is probably not for you.

robinb 11-15-2012 10:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cookieswithangel
Thanks for the feedback! I guess the only real way to see if its even possibly worth it would be to price out everything. (that's where 14 nights is a bit of a pain to figure out all those meals!)
I really do hope they offer FD to make the DxDP a no-brainer for us, but for now I guess we'll just have to think about what all we would eat and if that's valued at $100 per person/night.

Have you considered getting an annual pass and then the Tables in Wonderland card? It will save you 20% on most TS and some CS including alcohol.

ETA: If you don't have an AP, what kind of ticket do you get? The TIW card is $75 and you have to spend $375 to break even. Everything else is gravy. It will expire about 13 months after you get it and you can pick it up from Guest Services at the parks or at DTD.

cookieswithangel 11-15-2012 12:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by robinb (Post 46714472)
Have you considered getting an annual pass and then the Tables in Wonderland card? It will save you 20% on most TS and some CS including alcohol.

We have thought about it, but we've never really looked into it. That might be an option to consider for us. Except with going for 14 days, we enjoy those water park days. We'd have to actually buy water park tickets if we had an AP, correct?
We will definitely take a look at the breakdown for the cost with TiW when we get together next week to crunch numbers.
Thanks for the idea!

And just to throw it out there, there are no kids in the party. Just one college kid and a mom. (:

jsw1114 11-15-2012 01:01 PM

What is the price difference between reg dining plan and deluxe? We have free dining for sept

Tigger's ally 11-15-2012 01:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cookieswithangel (Post 46715295)
We have thought about it, but we've never really looked into it. That might be an option to consider for us. Except with going for 14 days, we enjoy those water park days. We'd have to actually buy water park tickets if we had an AP, correct?
We will definitely take a look at the breakdown for the cost with TiW when we get together next week to crunch numbers.
Thanks for the idea!

And just to throw it out there, there are no kids in the party. Just one college kid and a mom. (:

Premium Annual pass may be your best bet as Water Parks are included.

christianweecare 11-15-2012 01:27 PM

DH & I have purchased the DXDP in the past and enjoyed having all our food paid for in advance. However, when we looked at it again for our upcoming Dec. trip we could not justify over $400 more for the DXDP for the week. I believe we will do just fine with the basic plan and just eat our breakfast in the room each morning. We can have a counter service lunch and a table service dinner each evening and be fine. The DXDP is just too expensive for us this time.

aaarcher86 11-15-2012 05:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jsw1114 (Post 46715520)
What is the price difference between reg dining plan and deluxe? We have free dining for sept

There is a sticky at the top of the forum with the exact prices, but off the top of my head for 2013 it's around $50 for an adult per night.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:58 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.

Copyright 1997-2014, Werner Technologies, LLC. All Rights Reserved.