The DIS Discussion Forums -

The DIS Discussion Forums - (
-   Disney Restaurants (
-   -   Which Signature Restaurant (

jcieutat 10-10-2012 04:56 PM

Which Signature Restaurant
We are doing one signature meal with our upcoming trip. Right now we have Yachtsman's Steakhouse booked. We have done Le Cellier the past few years and decided to try something new. It will be Myself, wife, and daughters 8 & 4. If we eat at Yachtsman's, we will more than likely not make it over to Downtown Disney during our trip. Would it be worth looking into a signature restaurant at Downtown Disney over Yachtsman's?

DisneyStarWisher 10-10-2012 09:38 PM

It seems as if you are asking which to choose-Yachtsman or DTD. I'm not a huge fan of DTD but after our meal at YSH last week, I would choose it any day! It was the 2nd worst dining experience I've had at WDW, after ABC Commissary! In fact, after the 3rd try to get my steak medium well instead of burnt hard-as-a-rock impossible-to-eat-without-breaking-a-tooth or mooing when I cut into it, they refunded my table service credits. I didn't even ask. The chef was truly embarrassed. I ate about 3 bites of steak and left hungry. My DH, DS16, and DS14 ordered porterhouses and were unimpressed; they said they were VERY gristly and hard to eat. We also eat at Le Cellier everytime we go and LOVE it. We've never had a bad meal there. So I would pick LC over Yachtsman any day!

Now, I don't have any advice for a signature at DTD, but if the choice was between California Grill and DTD, definitely CG!!! It was the best dining experience I've ever had at WDW!

Pakey 10-10-2012 09:52 PM

The only signatures at DTD are Fulton's and Wolfgang Pucks The Dinjng Room.

I'm not a huge fan of Yachtsman, except for the filet which can be ordered everywhere, the other cuts have been tough. It's an OK restaurant. I've had the New York, the ribeye and the filet and I've only been happy with the filet. I like my steaks very rare and they have been prepared properly but the steaks were so tough. Service has always been very good. We prefer Shulas.

I have not been to the DTD ones since they came on the Dinjng plan this year. The Dining Room used to not be child friendly; I'm sure that has changed now. Fulton's is OK, I like it better than Narcoosees but not as much as Bluezoo or Flying Fish.

DisneyDetective 10-11-2012 05:44 AM

I love going to Downtown Disney however the area doesn't have a restaurant that would match the YSH. I would go to the YSH then go to DTD or just wonder round YBC or Boardwalk area.

sephorachick 10-11-2012 06:36 AM

We went to Yachtsmen last week & LOVED it. Amazing meal. Get the truffle mac & cheese! Walk around boardwalk after YSH dinner. :) HTH:thumbsup2

Uncleromulus 10-11-2012 12:23 PM

Sounds like you have to decide if going to DD is worth it rather than a good meal. (For me personally, the answer is a resounding NO)

If DD is a must, then I guess Fultons or Pucks "fine dining" are ok. Neither are my favorite spots on property by any means. I'd even suggest Portobello over either of them.

If a good meal wins the contest, the do YSH for steak. As Pakey says, Shulas is much better--but they aren't exactly kid friendly, and you can't even see what's on the limited kids menu until you actually get to the restaurant.

PS: I assume that steak is the primary goal at dinner??

3pletprincesses 10-11-2012 01:49 PM

Yatchman is our fav with california Grill. We would pick that over DTD. We are not huge fan of DTD. If we eat there, we usually end up at Wolf Gang counter service

jcieutat 10-11-2012 09:00 PM

I think we are just gonna stick with Yachtsman's. Not going to downtown Disney will save us some cash by avoiding the large princess store! Thanks for all the input.

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:59 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.

Copyright 1997-2014, Werner Technologies, LLC. All Rights Reserved.