I'm having the same conundrum, but will be sticking with Sapphire since 1) I'm getting the exact same price at both hotels with the AP discount, 2) the boats, 3) it's new. If I don't enjoy my stay then I just won't stay there again. I get too wrapped up in reviews all the time, and find I will sometimes have completely different opinions. The only time I felt reviews were actually on point was when I ate at Hollywood and Vine at DHS, the food was not horrible but definitely not good. Even a hotel that had miserable reviews I found to be better than I expected. I mean the hotel wasn't great, but it wasn't as bad as I was expecting.