LeeAndRobin
Mouseketeer
- Joined
- Sep 3, 2014
Just a quick reply to address some clarifications, I may expound more later....
No, I'm saying that there are many, many guests who chose to stay off-site (or are locals). They park at the TTC and most use the monorail to get to the MK (and a few no doubt to Epcot). My contention is that adding buses + ferries to carry all those people into the MK will cost more than doing the same with the existing monorail. If the monorail does indeed service 100,000 passenger trips per day, that's a lot of buses and a lot of bus trips back and forth...
You on the other hand seem to be under the misapprehension that everyone who goes to WDW stays on-site in a WDW resort.
But if you are going to replace the monorail, you have to look at all possible transport options to do so. The only possible non-resort ones are ferries and buses. It is the cost of those two combined, vs. continuing to use the monorail, which determine whether it is economical to continue to run and eventually upgrade the monorail trains. You have to get those people from the TTC parking lot to the MK somehow.
I was only comparing the number of drivers to each other in the two cases. It takes about 6 buses (likely more like 12 buses, given the longer time a round-trip bus would take (including loading/unloading time)) to replace one monorail train. And to reiterate here, I'm mostly talking about the "express loop" that just takes guests from the TTC to the MK and back. Not the resort or epcot loop.
You're right, I neglected the 4-6 cast members that work at each monorail stop. If we're talking the express loop, that's 12 cast members. If there are two trains running on the express loop, that's 6 extra cast members per train, or 7 total with driver, for a total of 14. So yes, that would be two more cast members total than 12 buses, assuming there would be ZERO cast members at any of the bus stops. That seems unlikely.
Yes, but I think you will find that it takes a lot more people than just a driver and a mechanic to keep a bus running. To claim that that is all that is required is not correct.
I'm not following you here. Are you implying that the parking lot by the TTC is filled with cars driven by guests from other onsite resorts?
No, I'm saying that there are many, many guests who chose to stay off-site (or are locals). They park at the TTC and most use the monorail to get to the MK (and a few no doubt to Epcot). My contention is that adding buses + ferries to carry all those people into the MK will cost more than doing the same with the existing monorail. If the monorail does indeed service 100,000 passenger trips per day, that's a lot of buses and a lot of bus trips back and forth...
You on the other hand seem to be under the misapprehension that everyone who goes to WDW stays on-site in a WDW resort.
No argument here. Differing opinions are always welcome. On the expense I'll refer back to my earlier comment about what true impact the absence of the monorail would be on transportation, and not a combination of all transportation options.
But if you are going to replace the monorail, you have to look at all possible transport options to do so. The only possible non-resort ones are ferries and buses. It is the cost of those two combined, vs. continuing to use the monorail, which determine whether it is economical to continue to run and eventually upgrade the monorail trains. You have to get those people from the TTC parking lot to the MK somehow.
To counter, I would be interested in your earlier comment about the six to one ratio on bus vs monorail drivers.
I was only comparing the number of drivers to each other in the two cases. It takes about 6 buses (likely more like 12 buses, given the longer time a round-trip bus would take (including loading/unloading time)) to replace one monorail train. And to reiterate here, I'm mostly talking about the "express loop" that just takes guests from the TTC to the MK and back. Not the resort or epcot loop.
I think what's forgotten is the staff required to maintain the monorails outside of mechanics and drivers. Ever count how many castmembers are at each monorail stop?
You're right, I neglected the 4-6 cast members that work at each monorail stop. If we're talking the express loop, that's 12 cast members. If there are two trains running on the express loop, that's 6 extra cast members per train, or 7 total with driver, for a total of 14. So yes, that would be two more cast members total than 12 buses, assuming there would be ZERO cast members at any of the bus stops. That seems unlikely.
How often the shift changes are (I personally don't know)? How many are in traffic control? How many are dedicated to maintaining the track? There's more than a driver and a mechanic to address.
Yes, but I think you will find that it takes a lot more people than just a driver and a mechanic to keep a bus running. To claim that that is all that is required is not correct.