OP
I can tell you the staff was thrilled with your tip.
Your tip was well in the top range. There is nothing wrong with that. I have heard of higher tips fwiw. It's a personal decision, and it varies, with services provided. And delivered service varies widely.
And therefore the tips do too.
I've heard and read about some stories the concierge team occasionally performs for pax. that would surprise many. In those incidences, a tip in you range would be in line. In fact even normal regular service deserves such a tip from what I've heard. Of course some give $50 for a B2B on the Fantasy.
I would love to share concierge stories, (That I read about) but that would be a breach of security.
And if those details got out, everyone would request them. In fact I'm impressed they haven't surfaced.
If you have kids, your right. It's like the Kid's Club in a concierge way. I've read about how they really take care of, and focus on the little ones.
Isn't it nice to be surprised occasionally?
We don't have to tell all here, do we?
Does no one want to be wowed/surprised?
I'm thrilled to hear your tip amount to the concierge team, and many others are too. Many now feel better. Of course some don't unfortunately. Because after reading some of these threads here, it seems few tip as high unfortunately. But again, those folks must not have met the team, or asked any questions, or had kids.
Fwiw, tipping the team is entirely personal and can range from $0 - $ 700 for a week sailing. You will become comfortable with a figure for the team during your sailing as all do. So try to relax and enjoy.
Concierge tipping amount poll, fwiw.
http://www.disboards.com/showthread.php?t=2971416&highlight=tipping+concierge+poll
Also, trust me that the bottom value in the poll is used, just no one reports it IMO. (96 votes) Lol.