American Idol Season 12 Official Thread

[Nancy]

Bottom 2 for me are Lazaro and Amber.

I actually think I'd rather see Amber go first, she just always sounds off tune to me.

 

[DarthKTrava]

She did try and at least did something relatively current

Moreso than the rest. ANd one of the top 2 or 3 perfomances tonight.

And now it's off to bed.

 

[TLSnell1981]

Orianthi

Performance of the night!

 

[Darcy03231]

My top two for the night were Kree and Angie.

Bottom two were Burnell and Lazaro.

 

[Robinrs]

Bottom 2 for me are Lazaro and Amber.

I actually think I'd rather see Amber go first, she just always sounds off tune to me.

But she's so beeYOUtiFUL.... are they KIDDING????

Lazaro has no business being on the stage, neither does Burnell, the guys are a joke.

Janelle is growing on me, Kree grew on me and became a fave, Candice is amazing, I could listen to her all day and Angie was good tonight but her moves turn me OFF. No one excites me at all.

Josh, what the HECK was on his head????

 

[asta]

Almost forgot to comment about Angie. For some reason I just don't enjoy her performances. This was just OK.

 

[happygirl]

My top 3
Angie
Kree
Janelle

My bottom three
Amber
Lazaro.
Burnell

 

[PammyK]

Almost forgot to comment about Angie. For some reason I just don't enjoy her performances. This was just OK.

Try closing your eyes when she sings. She has a tendency to overperform/over-emote all of her songs and comes across as unnatural and unappealing because of it. But if you close your eyes it is easier to appreciate that gorgeous tone she was gifted with.

 

[dizzwizz]

Does anyone here besides me think Angie looks like a young Marie Osmond? Big saucer eyes and lots of teeth.

 

[tennvalgirl]

Does anyone here besides me think Angie looks like a young Marie Osmond? Big saucer eyes and lots of teeth.

Yes! All she is missing is the dark hair

 

[tennvalgirl]

Try closing your eyes when she sings. She has a tendency to overperform/over-emote all of her songs and comes across as unnatural and unappealing because of it. But if you close your eyes it is easier to appreciate that gorgeous tone she was gifted with.

I would rather listen to her than watch her so this makes sense.

 

[KristaTX]

Does anyone here besides me think Angie looks like a young Marie Osmond? Big saucer eyes and lots of teeth.

I haven't been able to keep up with this thread this year, but I'm trying my best. This may have already been mentioned, but I think she looks like Pam Dawber. But I can also see the Marie Osmond look to her. Maybe if Pam Dawber and Marie Osmond had a baby together?

 

[smidgy]

I haven't been able to keep up with this thread this year, but I'm trying my best. This may have already been mentioned, but I think she looks like Pam Dawber. But I can also see the Marie Osmond look to her. Maybe if Pam Dawber and Marie Osmond had a baby together?

OMG! I couldn't thinkwho she reminded me of until you said that! you are so right!

I am still a fan of hers, but I am moving into the Kree camp! I love bluesy girls (loved haley rhinehardt, loved crystla bowersox) .
but when the other's talked about kree they related how she knew the names, etc of so many people. I can relate to that.I am a bartender and a waitress and the other girls at work tease me cause I always know the customers names, their "stories", thier kids names, etc. they always hug me, so, I guess I can relate to Kree. being friendly is just something that comes naturally.. either you have it or you don't.

 

[Caseheidi]

Loving the live band tonight, but the balance is coming out all wrong on our TV. This is something DH has been complaining about since season 1. There are many points where the contestants voice is lost in the band, and the back-up singers are louder then the front man! Just annoys me, especially as it is out of their control!

Now that the rant is over I love the intros of contestants talking about each other. So fun.

 

[Robinrs]

I haven't been able to keep up with this thread this year, but I'm trying my best. This may have already been mentioned, but I think she looks like Pam Dawber. But I can also see the Marie Osmond look to her. Maybe if Pam Dawber and Marie Osmond had a baby together?

She sort of reminds me of Pam Dawber... another ol'lady remembrance... Mork and Mindy?

Angie is SINGING this song!!

nano nano

We brought this up back in March! She really does look like Pam Dawber, once she sticks her wet finger in a socket!

 

[KristaTX]

Ha! I knew she looked like Mindy!!

 

[kimmar067]

Bottom 2 for me are Lazaro and Amber.

I actually think I'd rather see Amber go first, she just always sounds off tune to me.

....you are so right....I don't see the appeal of Amber.

 

[mandy200587]

I predict next week will set the leagues apart as far as who can handle the themes. Yes there are two themes!

 

[kimmar067]

I predict next week will set the leagues apart as far as who can handle the themes. Yes there are two themes!

....okay.....let's have it....

 

[mandy200587]

Themes are:
Bacharach-David Songbook
Free Choice, billed as "Songs You Wish You Wrote"