rentayenta
DIS Veteran
- Joined
- Feb 28, 2007
Devastating for the family. My thoughts go out to them.
That's a load of garbage. This kind of thing happens at home, in high schools and colleges all over the country. WAY more often than it does on ANY cruise line.........
And if you see the post above, a quote from a family member, then the parents share the blame. I'd read that they weren't in the same room with their son all night......they took responsibilty, rather than let the cruise line's medical center do it, and now they have to live with that decision.
I thought you didn't want this to turn into a debate. You are all over these boards arguing with people when something bad happens on a Carnival ship. No one in this thread made any derogatory remarks except for you. So, please heed your own advice and steer this thread back on topic.
Agreed. This is not, and should not be, about demonizing one particular cruise line over another. But teens drink too much and get alcohol poisoning on land. IMO, it's the same parenting failure to supervise and educate kids on responsibility.
To some extent, there may be a "cruise" aspect that worsens this - I do agree with the alleged Royal Caribbean quote above that the cruise is not a babysitting service. I've seen lots of parents abdicate responsibility for their kids because "it's my vacation, too," and while I have no idea if that was what happened here, I think there's a greater risk of teens getting into trouble on cruise lines (any line) than at home because of that mentality that mom and dad deserve a break and someone else is responsible for the kids. There are lots of discussions about how much "freedom" tweens and teens get on ships, and lots of people whom I otherwise respect and admire make choices in this area that make me uncomfortable about the level of supervision. It's plain to me, though, that there are different choices made about supervision on cruise ships versus an ordinary night at home.
ITA that this could happen at home. Way back when -- kids use to break into their parents' liquor cabinets during parties starting in 5th grade. I would call to be picked up then. The drinking continued through school and today there is much more kids get into that they shouldn't. The parents probably would have handled this at home the same way they did on the ship. They would have taken the kid home and put him to bed to sleep it off. If he was in his own room at home, the brother wouldn't have been there to hear him struggling. He would have then been found when everyone else woke up. They may not have realized what could happen so thought he would be fine since he was "safe" in bed. It makes me wonder if anything would have been different if the parents had put him in their room. They would have been sleeping and been woken up by the same sounds the brother was, possibly with the same results. Perhaps there wasn't another bed for their son to sleep on in their room? No matter what, this is tragic.
I guess here's a question - does a cruise ship infirmary have the ability to test blood alcohol levels? Knowing how bad it was may have influenced the decision to let the kid sleep it off in his room If it were apparent that he was dangerously intoxicated and not just drunk, maybe he would have stayed in the infirmary, or could they induce vomiting/pump his stomach? Just wondering. I have to imagine that badly intoxicated people, both teens and adults, are a fact of life at any vacation destination, certainly including cruise ships.
Thank you for assuming you know what I mean. I've sailed on 4 different cruiselines (and Carnival is not one of them) and the "booze, booze, booze" mentality has been present to some degree on all of them (more on some than others). And that *includes* DCL.I didn't specify any particular cruise line. But you just did.
And with the comment of "booze, booze, booze", most of us know which cruise line the other person was talking about also. I made no derogatory comments.
I don't think it's actually written on the KTTW cards, but if they are swiped, they can tell how old you are.So sad...I can't even imagine what that family is going through.
Does DCL have any way of putting ages on the room keys? Just wondering if/how people can be "carded" on the cruise when ordering drinks so they don't have to carry ID...
So sad...I can't even imagine what that family is going through.
Does DCL have any way of putting ages on the room keys? Just wondering if/how people can be "carded" on the cruise when ordering drinks so they don't have to carry ID...
The actual age isn't on there, but there is a difference between the legal ADULT cards and the non-adult cards.
Kids don't have to get liquor from the bars. Their parents and their friends' parents carry on a ton of it. All they have to do is swipe a bottle. Just like at home.
Maybe DCL should reconsider their policy of allowing people to bring alcohol onboard, in light of this incident.
The actual age isn't on there, but there is a difference between the legal ADULT cards and the non-adult cards.
Kids don't have to get liquor from the bars. Their parents and their friends' parents carry on a ton of it. All they have to do is swipe a bottle. Just like at home.
Maybe DCL should reconsider their policy of allowing people to bring alcohol onboard, in light of this incident.
So sad...I can't even imagine what that family is going through.
Does DCL have any way of putting ages on the room keys? Just wondering if/how people can be "carded" on the cruise when ordering drinks so they don't have to carry ID...
If he died from aspiration (vomiting and then having vomit enter your airways), then it's possible that observation in the med center might not have even prevented his death. The only positive thing to come out of this, is that every student in his school, and all who hear of the story, may be a bit more wary about drinking alcohol to such an extent, or stop a friend before they become so drunk. So hopefully this story might save another's life. It should be shared with other teenagers.