Best Seafood Signature Restaurant?

[L-Harper]

DH and I are possibly changing our October trip to WDW into just the two of us instead of our whole family. If we do we will get the Deluxe Dining Plan and want to have a few signature meals. We are seafood junkies and want your opinions on where to get the best seafood in WDW. Reviews and photos are MUCH appreciated!

 

[DEA]

As a dark horse candidate, I've gotten some very good seafood at Artists Point, but FF is still my top choice.

 

[katrina1122]

I've only done Fulton's of those, but we loved it so much in Nov we are going back in March. Our server was the best of the whole trip and we loved the food.

 

[L-Harper]

I've only done Fulton's of those, but we loved it so much in Nov we are going back in March. Our server was the best of the whole trip and we loved the food.

Honestly, Fulton's is where I'm leaning... but still wanting to get people's reviews and opinions. What did you have? I'd love to hear some details on particular dishes.

 

[cwt580]

Narcossee for surf and turf and fireworks on the deck with music.....

 

[MrEVILdrPorkchop2u]

We are just back from Disney. We ate at Narcosee's the 3rd night we were there. 5 of us had the surf and turf and it was wonderful! My wife had made 8:45 reservations for my 40th Birthday. They gave us a table looking straight across from the castle. Amazing dinner in so many ways! Service was wonderful. New favorite place to dine!

 

[DizDaD7]

Most people will say FF or Nar. But honestly I love Fulton's. We will be heading to Fulton's this next trjp before our big group of friends arrive 2 days later. Can't wait.

 

[Sweettears]

I like all three but for different reasons.

Fulton's seems to have the widest selection of seafood. Fish, lobster, crab
Flying Fish has a more limited range but is more creative.
Narcoossee's for the lobster and the view. Only place to get whole maine lobster in WDW.

 

[Peter Pirate 2]

Been to all of them many times and the CG is still the best (if it is open by then). Next is AP, then FF.

 

[figment_jii]

My favorite is Narcoossee's. I usually get the calamari or crab cakes for an appetizer and then the whole Maine lobster for my entree. The "surf and turf" option is also really good.

Calamari:

Crab Cakes:

Whole Maine Lobster:

Filet Mignon with Cold Water Lobster Tail:

 

[L-Harper]

My favorite is Narcoossee's. I usually get the calamari or crab cakes for an appetizer and then the whole Maine lobster for my entree. The "surf and turf" option is also really good.

Whole Maine Lobster:

This. Looks. Amazing! I have a soft spot for lobster. YUM! You may have just sealed the deal.

 

[amypetecar]

Sounds like you have great advice for the signatures. Since you are seafood junkies, and may have 3 TS credits a day, i have enjoyed:


- cape may buffet for dinner. Mostly seafood and only 1 credit
- coral reef, not as good as other restaurants, but still good for 1 credit
- rose and crown has really good fried fish and chips. I love seafood and sometimes youre just in the mood for a good fried fish.. Simple but delicious!
- scallops at teppen edo also get rave reviews
- san angel inn also has a great fish entree if you like a mexican flare to your fish

 

[Pakey]

The best is Bluezoo but it's not on the dining plan.

On the plan I'd pick FF then Fulton's then Narcoosees.

 

[Big E]

Stay away from FF - awful scallops

 

[CLEO Z]

Narcossee for surf and turf and fireworks on the deck with music.....

My DH and I went there for a date night during our last trip. We couldn't get the fireworks on the deck and it was still romantic. The surf and turf was to die for.

 

[AirGoofy]

I like Narcoosee's for the lobster and Fulton's for the King Crab Claws. We had a bad meal at FF the last time, so it will be awhile before we return.

 

[PoohsFan1]

My family loves Narcoossee's. The surf and turf is excellent, but after looking at the whole main lobster picture, I am thinking I am going to have to try that one next time . My family tried Fulton's for the first time this past September and had an excellent meal there as well. I had the King Crab Legs (my absolute favorite dish ever ) while both my DD11 and DH had the lobster and crab leg meal. DD11 was a little put off by the lobster because it didn't look like the lobster tail that she shared with me when we were dining at Narcoossee's....the one at fulton's still had the head, eyes, and tentacles. DH had to help her with it because she or I would not touch it . Once she was able to start eating the meat, she loved her meal...she has really become quite a lobster lover since this trip. As for my DD9, she is not that adventurous .

 

[tinacaplan]

I'd go for FF. We had an excellent meal there. Being from New England, Narcoosee's lobster doesn't impress me. The red snapper at FF, on the other hand... and my husband had scallops and crab cakes there, as well, and loved them.

 

[purple figment]

The people in our family really like the lobster at Narcoossee's and I've had the crabcakes which are also excellent.

A close second is the potato wrapped snapper at Flying Fish.

Also very good are the scallops at Cali Grill and the salmon at Artist's Point.

 

[Sweettears]

I'd go for FF. We had an excellent meal there. Being from New England, Narcoosee's lobster doesn't impress me. The red snapper at FF, on the other hand... and my husband had scallops and crab cakes there, as well, and loved them.

Been to the Cape at least 13 times. A fresh Maine lobster is a fresh Maine lobster. I have them several times a year in Illinois. What's the difference?