I agree.. I'm little concerned because I've been on 5 cruises and I never thought the food was so bad it was inedible. And, I feel like I have pretty fancy tastes in my food requirements. There was always something I could enjoy at any of the restaurants, quick service, etc... Now, I do believe my food tastes have changed a lot since I've had kids ;-)
I never said it was "inedible". I said it was disappointing. Please, everyone, don't put words in my mouth. I am not angry, but I see this happen a lot in threads where people take another poster's comments to an extreme that is not accurate.
I had read MANY threads raving about their food experiences. I did not think it would be 5-star, I did not expect fine dining. I did expect to have a few mediocre meals (come in, it's a cruise AND it's Disney--I was prepared for some shortcomings in the food department), but I also expected to have a few that made me go "Wow, this is yummy!" I never had that latter experience, it was all mediocre and some were truly bad. As I said, overcooked, overly salty, fatty, etc. This doesn't render them inedible, but it sure does spoil the fullest enjoyment of a meal of any quality or expectation. And as indicated by many comments here, others agree with this sentiment; and so, too, there were people with better experiences than mine. All this information is valuable to me in the context of my original posted question.
I see alot of people complaining but do you say anything? If you don't like it, it tastes bad SEND IT BACK!
I know this thread is long, but if you had read it fully before commenting you would see why I didn't send it back. I never left hungry, but I never left happy either. I didn't order anything else because 1) To order something else would have delayed our entire table's meal/evening, which is something I didn't want to do, and 2) I tasted other things my tablemates had ordered and none of them were any better, so I was never convinced it was worth delaying everyone's dinner to get something else that wasn't going to improve it.
And clearly I am not alone in my assessment--there are many people here who have admitted to similar disappointment. So please, understand that everyone has different experiences than you and it is no reflection on you personally. Try to empathize with what it would have been like if you had gone on a fun vacation and never left a meal with a food-induced smile on your face. Kind of a bummer, right? That is the source of my disappointment.
As to the suggestion made above to go on another cruise line, this is part of why I started the thread, as you can see from my original post. We have been researching that possibility. But also as I said in previous posts, we love everything else about Disney, and we were hoping this was just a fluke and we would be assured that it would be better on another ship or itinerary. Sadly, it is not stacking up that way. BUT, the question for us is this: is the other Disney touches important enough to take another gamble on the food? We are leaning toward yes, because we loved so much else about our trip!
But it is a fair question we will continue to investigate before we book again. Thanks!