Good/Bad Internet and eBay Pin Sellers

[cootiezoo]

I have purchased booster sets from marme07 and kittykat2bad. Shipping was fast and the sets were all brand new.

 

[SupernaturalMommy]

I've been away from pin buying too long! Anyone have any experience with:
mad4disneytoo or mousepintrader? Thanks!

I would give mad4disneytoo a shot depending on what you are looking at. I looked at their auctions and most of their stuff is new on card. A lot of the loose pins don't come on cards originally. The HM stuff is where you tend to run into trouble, but I don't see anything suspicious about them. The 2 neutral feedbacks look undeserved and they leave great feedback. That is important to look at believe it or not. They have some great pins I would love to add to my collection but until I can sell off some of my duplicates I can't buy anymore :-(

mouspintrader looks good as well, however a lot of their pins are available all over ebay right now and you may be able to find a better price from a good seller, so search by the specific pins you want in a new window before you hit buy it now. Again, looking at their feedback, all five of their neutrals were from one buyer and it was over the quality of the card, not the pins. And, they leave great feedback. A lot of sellers have it on auto, but a lot don't leave any at all. I saved both of these sellers as searches because I think they look good.

 

[SupernaturalMommy]

I wish I could find Traders in the Philly Area and do a Philly Pin Trader Dis Meet. I have soooooo many pins, too many to carry to Disney. There is a great one in Central Jersey, but something always comes up on those weekends. plus it's a 2 hour car ride. Maybe someday we Philly people will get it together. LOL

Start something up yourself. It may not be as hard as you think. Check local restaurants to see if they have space to loan you for meets. We do Fuddruckers. They let us use the space for free. They have all of us buying meals so they do make money. They have a separate room they use for busy days that we meet in. We are there from open until as late as dinner time. Otherwise there are a lot of public areas you could probably use for free. Get the buzz going with a yahoo group and put it in your signature anywhere you are allowed. Post about it anywhere you can. Generate a buzz. When you start seeing a lot of people joining, that is the time to try to put together a meet. We have been at three Fuddruckers because the first one closed down. The second wasn't as thrilled to have us there. One of the managers from the original moved to a new location and welcomed us with open arms there, but she couldn't give us the food discount we used to get at the original.

Sorry this went off-topic. Hope that is ok. Just trying to help out a fellow trader.

 

[SupernaturalMommy]

ordered from disneypinsandvinylmation and received them yesterday- they were all sealed in their packages and exactly as advertised!

irbliquidators seemed to have a few legit and a few scrappers- but refunded half my money and let me keep the pins - so not the worst- but not the best either

I loved disneypinsandvinylmation... Only thing I don't like is there were no Buy It Nows. I had to wait and bid. But, I got a lot of stuff last minute with no one bidding on it. They have a few things now I want, but I am so broke lol... I did break down and buy another booster pack from brandnamestuff. I really wanted it, and they had the best price plus free shipping. Most sellers were breaking it up and selling it off pin by pin. It was one I couldn't wait to see if I could get in November. I had to have it now!

 

[SupernaturalMommy]

I have purchased booster sets from marme07 and kittykat2bad. Shipping was fast and the sets were all brand new.

Thanks for the heads up on marme07. I saved the seller as a search. Their stuff looks good.

 

[mouselike-harrier]

Thank you SupernaturalMommy for replying! I am going to give mad a try. Will post about my experience.

 

[SupernaturalMommy]

Thank you SupernaturalMommy for replying! I am going to give mad a try. Will post about my experience.

Great! And you are welcome. Let us know!

 

[chaoscent]

Start something up yourself. It may not be as hard as you think. Check local restaurants to see if they have space to loan you for meets. We do Fuddruckers. They let us use the space for free. They have all of us buying meals so they do make money. They have a separate room they use for busy days that we meet in. We are there from open until as late as dinner time. Otherwise there are a lot of public areas you could probably use for free. Get the buzz going with a yahoo group and put it in your signature anywhere you are allowed. Post about it anywhere you can. Generate a buzz. When you start seeing a lot of people joining, that is the time to try to put together a meet. We have been at three Fuddruckers because the first one closed down. The second wasn't as thrilled to have us there. One of the managers from the original moved to a new location and welcomed us with open arms there, but she couldn't give us the food discount we used to get at the original.

Sorry this went off-topic. Hope that is ok. Just trying to help out a fellow trader.

Good advice, thank you.

 

[SupernaturalMommy]

Good advice, thank you.

You are welcome! Hope it works out.

 

[daisy 'n donald]

i just got some more from disneypinsandvinylmation...and the packages look new and sealed....
the pins from them are great, just a bummer that you have to bid....i've won a 9 booster sets from them, but 3 different payments.....i'm waiting on the last 2 sets.....but i'd buy from them again

also won some sets from angali35....these too were bids on booster sets and they look new and unopened to me as well

also just got a package from gitanoman....i've bought from them in the past, but it was more of a loose lot and they were legit..the most recent ones i won (also by bidding, not buy it now) were unopened booster sets....and they look new to me too

lastly i won a set from kittykat2bad...i'm still waiting for them to be delivered..i won them the same time as the gitanoman auction...

dh wanted to get a lot of pins to trade, but i think between the 6 sets of purchases i made from these 4 sellers we have a little over 100 pins...which is good bc i think there actually might be a couple or so we'll want to keep.....and i also did not win any duplicate booster sets....even tho 2 of the ones i won i purposely set out to trade for last time...go figure....i'm cuties fan....

i would recommend these sellers and would buy from them again....well, i still hold out comment on kittykat2bad just because i haven't received my package yet, but i read good things about them before

 

[abbadabbadoo]

Just wanted to share a few of my recent pin purchases from ebay:

Purchased a few things from kittykat2bad. All were brand new sealed in package. I purchased from them twice in a 10-day period, and the second transaction took a while to ship to me. All pins were great though.

Purchased 2 lots of pins (each lot had 25) from disneyfamily801. I think I received 5 scrappers in the lot of 50. She did offer to refund my money, but I told her I wanted to send the ones back to her that I suspected were scrappers and have her replace them with new ones. She agreed to it, and after 10 days of sending them back I did receive 5 more that look to be authentic.

Purchased from eside56. Everything purchased from them appears to be authentic and in great shape.

Overall I've had positive experiences purchasing pins on ebay. I'm grateful to this thread for keeping me informed on what to look for as far as scrappers are concerned.

 

[SupernaturalMommy]

i just got some more from disneypinsandvinylmation...and the packages look new and sealed....
the pins from them are great, just a bummer that you have to bid....i've won a 9 booster sets from them, but 3 different payments.....i'm waiting on the last 2 sets.....but i'd buy from them again

dh wanted to get a lot of pins to trade, but i think between the 6 sets of purchases i made from these 4 sellers we have a little over 100 pins...which is good bc i think there actually might be a couple or so we'll want to keep.....and i also did not win any duplicate booster sets....even tho 2 of the ones i won i purposely set out to trade for last time...go figure....i'm cuties fan....

He he, I wonder if you are the one who kept outbidding me on the disneypinsandvinylmation sets

I usually take 150 to 200 pins to trade and end up running out before our trip is over. I trade like crazy. I don't know how many to take for my cruise, and my trip to the park is going to be so much shorter this time that I don't want to pack too many but also don't want to be short in case a cast member has something I really want.

Thanks for letting us know about the other sellers and let us know how the newest purchases turn out. I am still waiting on some purchases dh made so I will post when they show up. Sadly I keep saying I have enough, but I never seem to have enough. I think I have a problem.

 

[mouselike-harrier]

My recent transaction....
I bought 2 pins from mousebuys. Both were sealed and look completey authentic. No problems and very quick shipping. Got them at great prices as well.
I bought one WDI pin from mad4disneytoo. It was sealed, on the correct backing, and looks great and authentic. Also, no problems and quick shipping.

Forgot to add, the WDI pin has the original Mickey's of Glendale sticker.

 

[Eosphotog]

Just wanted to share a few of my recent pin purchases from ebay:

Purchased 2 lots of pins (each lot had 25) from disneyfamily801. I think I received 5 scrappers in the lot of 50. She did offer to refund my money, but I told her I wanted to send the ones back to her that I suspected were scrappers and have her replace them with new ones. She agreed to it, and after 10 days of sending them back I did receive 5 more that look to be authentic.

I purchased a lot of 25 from disneyfamily801 and I had 10 confirmed fakes (typos, wrong colors, wrong finish, wrong thickness), and 10 suspected fakes (rough edges, imperfect finishes). The remaining 5 were clean.

They offered a refund, but I like the "Swap for clean ones" idea since some of these were soooo bad.

I've had FAR better luck buying booster packs. Just picked up 3 sealed packs for $23 which gives me 15 pins. For authentic pins I can't really beat that price, and I can trade them with confidence.

 

[Eddygirl]

I had an awful experience with 52JCMdisneypins. I bought a lot of 30 2 years ago before our trip for the kids to trade. When I got them it just did not seem "right" so I started checking online....holy cow...I did not even know what a scrapper or fake was!! The pins I got were I am pretty sure either counterfeit or scrappers. They all came in little baggies with instructions to "be sure to take the pins out and put them on your lanyard before going to the park". Most of the pins had the Mickeyhead imprints on the backs....no clean edges. Classic counterfeit. The others were either off colour or pitted. There were maybe 3 in the whole lot that I could not tell 100% if they were either real or fake.

Geez...never knew I would be such an expert on spotting fake Disney pins...all I wanted to do was get some traders for the kids. Little did I know!!!

I documented each pin front and back with photos and sent the info to the anti-piracy dept and followed up with a phone call. I was so mad!!! It totally took some of the magic out of planning our first DL trip. That made me mad! Disney did not seem to be concerned really. I ended up filling with Paypal. They made me send the pins back at my expense for a refund. I neg'd the seller. I ended up getting some good pins from different sellers before I got the bad batch, enough for the kids to have fun....that was the main thing.

We are going back to DL and I have been collecting pins from Ebay for a while.....NO BIG LOTS! I learned my lesson. I have been using your guide as to which sellers should be okay. THANK-YOU!! I have been buying individual pins, and asking questions if I am not sure. I have a nice supply for the kids and as far as I can tell they are good pins. I did buy some pins from Sleepy's Emporium, individually no lots though, and they all look good. The ones with the Mickey Head stamps on the back look good, nice and clean. None of them are suspect on the lists of bad pins. So I had a good experience with him.

Thank-you so much for this thread! It has helped me and I feel good about giving the kids pins to trade.....even knowing half of the pins they end up with are probably going to be fakes.

 

[Eosphotog]

Geez...never knew I would be such an expert on spotting fake Disney pins...all I wanted to do was get some traders for the kids. Little did I know!!!

I think one of the most valuable aspects of building a collection to trade in the part is I quickly got a good idea of the quality of commonly available scrappers. We're not the only ones who bought these lots, and we're certain to find these on CM lanyards, so seeing some in advance will certainly help filtering out pins that aren't legit.

Thankfully I was able to pick up inexpensive boosters ($2-$3/pin) from bizzybee1, pins4mepins4you, and pintastic_78. These pins all were clean, or came sealed.

 

[SupernaturalMommy]

I have a serious problem. I can't stop buying pins. There are a lot of mystery pins I want but to buy them all individually cost a fortune so I have been looking for sellers selling the whole packs at what seem to be good prices, and taking my chances on getting what I want. I just found some new ones that I have not purchased from before. The pictures show brand new packs. I will let you know when I get them if they are good.

I LOVE Jessicaswholesale. She mostly sells coins but she throws in some Disney pins and they are really good prices. My husband and I both bought from her lol...

Just tried out vinylmations, disneypinfanatics and dizneestuff1. We'll see how it goes.

 

[SupernaturalMommy]

rememberme sent me a great LE pin that I just love. Excellent transaction. The pin was used but in beautiful condition and well packaged.

Got a new package from disneypinsandvinylmation... love their stuff but it was horribly packaged with already used bubble mailers cut and pieced together to make a package. And, I paid a LOT of money for shipping from them to get that kind of packaging. Not happy with that but the pins are great.

Then, guess what, got my package from disneypinfanatics and it was identical packaging. Can't complain about it too much this time because it was free shipping, but it was not only identical packaging but it was also same address and last name as disneypinsandvinylmation. Nothing wrong with having more than one selling id. Just letting you know that they apparently took an ID registered in 2008 that was never used and decided to start selling on it. Only 21 feedback as of today, but they are the same person as disneypinsandvinylmation so I would assume you will get the same service and quality. Of course I didn't know that until I purchased from them. I was taking a chance on a "new seller". Turned out fine. Still waiting on another purchase from the second id. The pins were perfect but the card got ruined from the poor packaging.

Still waiting, also, on some other purchases. Tracking numbers were supplied days ago but they haven't been shipped yet apparently. I'll post when I get them.

 

[cootiezoo]

I believe that I received scrappers from stevenbeck1682012. Someone left him negative feedback (posted after I made my purchase) for the exact same pins that I purchased and they received scrappers from him as well. It looks like he is selling the same pins over and over again. Highly suspect!

I received a booster set that I purchased from welovemmouse, it was packaged well and looks good!

 

[SupernaturalMommy]

Dizneestuff1 - great pin packs, unopened, carefully shipped, reasonable price. A little more than I usually pay per pin on pin packs for trading, but these were ones I wanted to keep so it was worth it. I would buy from them again with no hesitation.

Domdisneypin - I am a repeat buyer and was happy with the loose pins I bought. They look quite legit, and to my knowledge there are no scrappers of the pins I bought. Obviously from previous posts I am fickle about how things are packaged, probably because I take such great care in packaging my sales for shipment, so I still say his packaging leaves something to be desired in protecting the pins, but they are nice and fairly priced for single pin items.

Gitanoman I normally love and am a repeat buyer. Just purchased a number of loose pins from him all advertised as new. 2 of them don't really look new, but are good quality and 1 has very obviously been through multiple trades and is in rough condition. The rest of the pins were beautiful.

Disneypinfanatics (same as disneypinsandvinylmation) had a great transaction this time. No funky packaging! Great pins, fair price.