Is it worth it to stay 2 nights? We plan on checking in at 1:00 to start the water park. My thought was we can swim as much as we want the next day and then check into a cheaper hotel for the next night because we want to go to an aquarium that is nearby also. I am finding that I am only saving around $40 because the other hotels I'm looking at are $$ too(this is for a holiday inn express) Would you just stay and have the convenience? I guess it's just killing me to pay almost $500 for two nights. Have you been to Great Wolf in Mason Ohio? Did you love it? Help me decide...Please!
We were actually just there (in Mason) on June 18th-19th. We live locally so it was only about a 25 minute drive from our home. We checked in around 10 am that Saturday and bought one wand for our kids to try MagiQuest while we waited to enter the water park at 1 pm. Our room was ready when we checked in a 10. I honestly don't know how they determine who is allowed to enter the water park before 1 and who should enter after 1 on any given day, as no lifeguards stopped to check our wristbands at 1 pm when we entered on Saturday--seems like we could have gone in earlier if we had wanted, and no one would have cared.
Our room was on the 4th floor so we had vaulted ceilings which made it seem very large. The bathroom was awkward--one of those where you have to walk all the way in and then close the door, otherwise the toilet is in the way of closing the door. Otherwise our room was very nice, clean and beds were quite comfy. It was a much larger room than I would have expected--and we only booked the cheapest room we could get--no bunk beds or anything.
We swam that first night for about 4 hours, then had dinner and cleaned up for bed. The next morning we were up early at 6 am (we are early risers). There was absolutely nothing you could do at the hotel that early. Arcade wasn't opening until 9 am, waterpark until 10 am. We actually drove home to check on our cats, had some breakfast and then drove back at 10 to use the waterpark again. They wanted $10 to rent a locker for the second days' storage of our things after checkout--so we just went to the water park in coverups and swimsuits, had a bag with a change of clothes in our car, and 5 hours later, changed into clothes in the lobby restroom. After spending over $260 for one night there, I didn't feel the need to spend another $10 to have a locker.
Overall, I would not stay there again unless I could get the room for more like $150. We certainly enjoyed ourselves, but there would have been nothing for us to do for 3 hours on Sunday, if we hadn't driven home to kill some time. I don't understand why Magiquest or the arcade weren't open earlier in the morning, we could have at least done that. We did not eat food on property other than at the Bear Claw Cafe and Pizza Hut Express. The food at those locations was fresh and tasty--and reasonably priced for where we were.
I am a bit of a Disney snob, so I couldn't help but compare the GWL to WL at Disney. There is no comparison. I'd say that if you plan to use the water park a lot, it might be worth your while to stay there two nights. If you're not coming from too far away, you might do all your waterpark stuff on your first day, then check out and head to your next destination in the morning, and drive home from there if you can.
Hope that helps some.