I thought it was a pretty humerous summary. Wonder where they came up with this stuff? "highly rated" before many people had even sailed in various rooms or decks!
I liked the comment about room 5188, which touts it as having a less breezy verandah than the other ones. Having seen the pictures of that verandah today, no wonder it's "less breezy." It's too small for a breeze to stop and linger there for any length of time!
There is also a typo, as they list room 5025 as an outside room, instead of 5024. And makes no mention of the extended size verandahs on most deck 5 verandah rooms, except for 5024 and 5524.
[But then, who am I to comment, having given lots of feedback on Dream rooms and locations just from looking at [or obsessively studying depending on how you look at it] pictures and deck plans!][/QUOTE
Yours has been valuable, helpful and true info...didn't mean to offend you by my comment above. That 'best cabin' website just didn't make sense to me.