PDA

View Full Version : Signature Restaraunt Help


jesswindsor
08-19-2011, 06:24 PM
Ok so I am trying to plan where we are going to eat on our trip. We will be on the DxDP. We will be staying for 19 days, and we wanted to do at least 4 Signature restaraunts. I have looked over all the menus and they all look good. I would like your feedback!!! I want to know, which one has the best atmosphere, best Appitizer/Entree and best dessert!! Thanks

This is for 2 adults no kiddies

Pakey
08-19-2011, 07:12 PM
Who is in your party? For me, that makes a difference.

My order of preference on the signatues is Flying Fish, Citricos, Jiko, Ca Grill, Brown Derby, Yachtsman, Artist Point and last is Narcoosees.

Citricos, Jiko and Artist Point are much quieter restaurants. Citricos, especially, offers nothing in the way of atmosphere that would interest a young child. Ca Grill and Narcoosees offer the best atmosphere for young diners because of the views.

I'm not a big eater and rarely do dessert so favorite dishes in all of these categories would be tough. At Flying Fish, I like the cheese plate. At Jiko, the soups are the stars IMO. At Citricos, I like the short ribs. Ca Grill is all about the sushi for me. Brown Derby has a nice fish entree. Yachtsman has great onion bread. My favorite thing at Artist Point is the berry cobbler. At Narcooses, I usually get the seasonal fish.

jesswindsor
08-19-2011, 08:14 PM
Thank you for your response, It is just going to be 2 adults, I have been looking into Ca Grill, I worry about the Susi, I have never eaten it before. I am willing to try anything and I was thinking that Ca Grill will probably be the best first Susi for me.

heatherandnick
08-19-2011, 09:15 PM
My opinion
Do ALL the signatures! You have 19 days on DxDP!!! Chances are, you will not want 3 meals most days, as the servings are huge. Plus, don't forget about the snack credits. I vote for 2 meals a day...one 1 credit and one signature. Then, you can hit them all (twice!!!)! How awesome! Have fun.:goodvibes

Redwitch
08-19-2011, 09:20 PM
I like Flying Fish, Jiko, Cali Grill and Yachtsman. Artist Point, Narcoosee and Citrico have been sometimes good, sometimes underwhelming. Brown Derby is good, but a little undeserving of the signature rating in my opinion, although I love the cobb salad and always enjoy my meals. As for favorites, I tend to choose different items each time I dine ~ variety is the spice of life.

Hootch
08-19-2011, 09:21 PM
in the Midwest. It was pig, pig, chicken, pig, etc. I was always worried about sushi because some people are fanatical about the rules of eating sushi. CG is a good place to start.

My personal favorites are Jiko, Flying Fish, Artist Point and Citricos. As always these are personal preferences. Artist Point is possibly my favorite because 1) I like bison and it's not available around my area very often and 2) I like the Western national park architecture that the whole Wilderness Lodge is based on.

Jungle Cruiser
08-19-2011, 09:36 PM
California Grill is my absolute favorite. I don't personally care for sushi but others I have dined with there say it's really good. The view from the restaurant is amazing and it is nice to watch the fireworks from the restaurant. My second favorite is Narccoosses. I love the location, ambiance and the food.

As with all recommendations you will get varying opinions. I would look at the menus of the restaurants that make the top of your list.

ls3015
08-19-2011, 11:31 PM
Yachtsman and Artist Point and shulus, are my must do's, I just don't fill no others are worth the extra costs.:goodvibes

jesswindsor
08-20-2011, 06:46 AM
Thank you to everyone!!

cbg1027
08-20-2011, 07:35 AM
My rankings of the Signatures on the DP:

1. Citricos
2. Tie between Flying Fish and Jiko
4. Cali Grill
5. Tie between Brown Derby and Artist Point
and way down at the bottom.....Narcoossee's
(I haven't been to Yachtsman Steakhouse).

Citricos and Artist Point have the most romantic, quiet, and relaxing ambiances.

Jiko is fairly low-key as well.

Cali Grill is loud, boisterous and has the most kids of any signature.

I think the best appetizers award goes to Jiko. I've had some amazing soup, the breads and dips basket is wonderful, and the red meat app dishes I've tried there were outstanding.

Best entrees I'd say Citricos (the fish dishes!), Flying Fish, or Cali grill.

Best desserts award goes to Flying Fish and Citricos.

If you only want to eat at four, I would recommend Citricos, Jiko, Flying Fish, and Cali Grill.

Swan4Me
08-20-2011, 09:14 AM
If you are childless and when you go not important-I'd push back the trip and go during the Food & Wine festival in Epcot(Oct-early Nov), go shorter time and ditch the Dining plan. You can easily eat 3-4 nights at the Festival and eat magnificent Gourmet food:thumbsup2

mickeynut1
08-20-2011, 09:56 AM
We've only been to 2 signature restaurants so far (Artist Point and Yachtsman Steakhouse) and both of those were amazing :thumbsup2. We have ADRs for Narccoossee's and Citricos this December and are looking forward to trying those :).

Kathy Z
08-20-2011, 10:14 AM
Ok so I am trying to plan where we are going to eat on our trip. We will be on the DxDP. We will be staying for 19 days, and we wanted to do at least 4 Signature restaraunts. I have looked over all the menus and they all look good. I would like your feedback!!! I want to know, which one has the best atmosphere, best Appitizer/Entree and best dessert!! Thanks

This is for 2 adults no kiddies

My opinion
Do ALL the signatures! You have 19 days on DxDP!!! Chances are, you will not want 3 meals most days, as the servings are huge. Plus, don't forget about the snack credits. I vote for 2 meals a day...one 1 credit and one signature. Then, you can hit them all (twice!!!)! How awesome! Have fun.:goodvibes

OP, I agree with Heather's advise to try them all and only doing 2 meals a day on the days you dine at a Signature restaurant. I read Heather's full report prior to our last trip and in addition to being a very entertaining writer she took great photos and gave spot on excellent advise.

"Hi, Heather. Enjoy your anniversary trip back to WDW!"

Back to OP, our favorite Signature restaurants in order would be:
1. Flying Fish - for atmosphere, location on the Boardwalk, appetizers (Jonah Crab Cake for me and the cheese plate for DH) and their signature potato wrapped snapper entree (me) or steak (DH). Right now I don't remember our desserts.
2. Artist Point - really ties for first place - quiet atmosphere in lovely WL, appetizer (smoky portebello soup, the best soup I've ever tasted in my life), cedar planked salmon or bison for entree and the berry cobbler ala mode for dessert.
3. Jiko - We stayed at the AKL so we were able to book the Sunset Safari which concluded with dinner at Jiko. So we had 3 selections from each part of the menu, along with wine pairings; what a delightful late afternoon/evening! My favorite appetizer was the chicken flat bread. My favorite entree was the fish with the beef filet a close second and the chicken was also fine. They all come with a nice vegetable side; different side for each entree selection. The trio of desserts we were served were nothing special but since I had noted on all of our dinner ADRs that we were celebrating our anniversary DH & I were presented with and additional dessert of strawberry gelato with fresh strawberries in a glass on a plate decorated with chocolate and berry piped hearts. We were the envy of the other 3 couples from the safari at our table.
4. Narcoosee's - beautiful location, fine food, great for watching wishes from the dock after dinner if you've timed it right. We just didn't love any dishes here as much as our top three favorite signatures.
5. Yachtsman - We've been here twice. Loved it the first time (2009), were terribly disappointed the second (and last) time (2010). Second time our filets were overcooked, the vegetables were terribly overcooked to the point of being inedible. The fine dessert could not make up for our general disappointment.

We've always loved Le Cellier in Epcot which is now a signature restaurant. Because of that I have made a lunch ADR at Le Cellier for our upcoming trip because lunch is still just 1 TS. We will be on just the DDP this next trip. I've got to have my fix of the beer cheese soup and pretzel bread. And their filets have sometimes been as good as in fine steak houses.

We've never been to Cali Grill, Citrico or the Brown Derby.

DonaldDoleWhip
08-20-2011, 11:42 AM
I think Artist Point is the best signature (I've been to all of them). The menu has some amazing dishes that are seasonal and often creative. My next choices would be Citricos and Yachtsman, then Jiko and Flying Fish.

heatherandnick
08-20-2011, 11:49 AM
OP, I agree with Heather's advise to try them all and only doing 2 meals a day on the days you dine at a Signature restaurant. I read Heather's full report prior to our last trip and in addition to being a very entertaining writer she took great photos and gave spot on excellent advise.

"Hi, Heather. Enjoy your anniversary trip back to WDW!"



:goodvibes Gosh, you're so sweet! Thanks for the well wishes for our trip. In one week we will be there and will be getting ready to eat at Jiko! I just can hardly wait!

Sappermont
08-20-2011, 12:09 PM
19 days on DXDP!!! Delicious!! I hope that you doing a dining trip report. Have fun!!!

hookedonears
08-20-2011, 12:17 PM
If you want to know where the best food at WDW is, go to the best resort. The Grand Floridian - Narcoossees & Citricos.

disneyfav4ever
08-20-2011, 02:06 PM
With 19 days I'd eat at all the signature restaurants too! I've done it with 13-days, and plan to do the same next year. You won't want a lot of days with 3 TS meals, it's a ton of food, using up credits on the signature restaurants is a much more reasonable amount of food.

From my favorite to least favorite, I'd rank them as follows;
Citricos
Jiko & Flying Fish (Tied)
California Grill
Brown Derby
Artist Point & Yachtasman Steakhouse (Tied)
Narcoossees

disneyfav4ever
08-20-2011, 02:08 PM
I read your post after I posted, but noticed we have almost exactly the same rankings! Great tastes!My rankings of the Signatures on the DP:

1. Citricos
2. Tie between Flying Fish and Jiko
4. Cali Grill
5. Tie between Brown Derby and Artist Point
and way down at the bottom.....Narcoossee's
(I haven't been to Yachtsman Steakhouse).

Citricos and Artist Point have the most romantic, quiet, and relaxing ambiances.

Jiko is fairly low-key as well.

Cali Grill is loud, boisterous and has the most kids of any signature.

I think the best appetizers award goes to Jiko. I've had some amazing soup, the breads and dips basket is wonderful, and the red meat app dishes I've tried there were outstanding.

Best entrees I'd say Citricos (the fish dishes!), Flying Fish, or Cali grill.

Best desserts award goes to Flying Fish and Citricos.

If you only want to eat at four, I would recommend Citricos, Jiko, Flying Fish, and Cali Grill.

Belle83
08-20-2011, 02:47 PM
The only signatures I've been to are California Grill, Shula's, and Bistro de Paris (I think that's a signature?).

California Grill is my favorite restaurant at WDW so far. It might even be my favorite restaurant, anywhere.

Based on other dining reviews I've read, my 4 picks for you would be:
- California Grill
- Jiko
- Artist Point
- Flying Fish Cafe