American Idol fans out there?

[Pumbaa_]

Okay, so who is going to win the American Idol?

I like Kelly and Nikki. Justin reminds me of a bobble-headed lounge singer! What do you think?

[Michelle]

TAMYRA should have won, sigh. :mad:

Now I'm pulling for Kelly.

Nikki has nowhere near the voice of Kelly and Tamyra and Justin is boy-band material.

[Beauty]

I've been 100 percent for Kelly from the start!!!

[Poohbear123]

Kelly Kelly Kelly!:p

[Eeyore's Buddy Bear]

I hope that Kelly and Justin are the final two. Kelly should win it all. She has an amazing voice!!

[daughter_of_amid_chaos]

Ok justin's a cutie and everything but Kelly is an AMAZING singer and deserves to win.

[Mr.MouseFan]

I've always been torn between Tamyra and Kelly. Now that Tamyra has been ousted (How terrible is that?), I'm 100% for Kelly. For some odd reason though, I have the horrible feeling Nikki is going to end up taking it all....and that would be a HUGE miscarriage of justice. Last week proved, you never know what's going to happen.

[supercarrie]

Kelly!

[Minnie824]

First of all Kelly should definitely win. She has an amazing voice! If Nikki doesn't get voted out this week, then something is fixed. She should not have made it this far especially ahead of Tamyra!

[Big Dude]

Justin Guarini

The Doylestown DJ! A natural ham, great voice and knows how to work the crowd. If it wasn't for his little ego trip with Simon awhile back, he would be the odds on favorite right now.

If Nikki doesn't get voted off tonight, I will not bother watching the remaining shows. Justin has been my #1 pick from the beginning (close to my home, fellow DJ, great talent) so that's my story and I'm sticking to it!;) ;) ;)

Adam aka Big Dude

[dizneenut]

I like both Justin & Kelly, but I think Kelly will win!! As long as Nikki doesn't win, I'll be a happy camper! :teeth:

[sharbear]

I got the feeling last night the judges were trying to influence the public to vote Nikki out. I think that they were shocked that Tamyra was voted off and they blamed themselves. This week they were bound and determined not to let that happen again. I think that they were right, Nikki sang well for her but she is just not in the same league. The judge pointed that out. Even though I thought that it was not Kelly's best night, I think that her voice is just giving out on her. The judges pointed out how much harder her songs were than the other contestants. They made that mistake last week, telling Tamyra that her performance was off when her songs were so much harder than Nikki's.

Hopefully the public listens to the judges and votes Nikki off, if not I think that a lot of people are going to be turn off. I know that if Kelly gets voted off I'm not sure I will watch the final. Who wants to see Justin and Nikki!

Sharbear

[elgerber]

I'm a big Kelly fan, her voice just amazes me. I really did not like Nikki's version of Edge of Seventeen. When they said she was singing Black Velvet, I thought that would be great for her, but she just did it boring. Justin is OK, but Kelly wows me every time she opens her mouth.

Erika

[Kteacher]

I hope it's Kelly that wins. Anyone else have a hard time getting through to call last night? I didn't get through until after 10:30!

[dizneenut]

I couldn't get through to call till after 11:00.

Did anyone else LOL when Nikki said she sounds like Stevie Nicks?? :rolleyes: :p

[Sean23]

Kelly and Justin will move on tonight and I think Kelly should win.

[elgerber]

I LOL, alot when Nikki said that. I don't really agree with her, and thought she was awfully full of herself saying that. Oh well, that's just me.

[Lola]

I loved Christina Christian, and I was kinda surprised to see her go .. After she was gone, I was torn between Tamyra and Kelly. I was in WDW when Tamyra got kicked off, and just caught the tail end of it .. Yehh that was a huge shock lol. So now I'm 100% Kelly. Nikki - ehh, seems like a Pink wanna-be too be lol. And Justin? Ohhh not one bit of me likes him!

[minniepumpernickel]

I still can't believe that Tamyra got voted off. Nicky is good at carioke type singing, and I agree that Kelly has a better voice. Justin is a good pop type. I hope Kelly wins!:D

[luvtogo12]

Kelly! She has an incredible voice and the sweetest dispositon. I just hope her remark last night "the competition is getting old" does not come back to haunt her. They are under so much pressure and it is live TV after all, but the media could have a blast with that statement.


Nikki has a nice voice but she in no Stevie Nicks!

[Minnie824]

For some reason, it seems to me like some of the people voting (I mean the people who call in, not just comment here) are voting for the wrong reasons. The one girl who wasn't there that week got voted off, then they seem to like a person more (obviously some people must like Nikki) and they don't get voted off. Then they let what judges say influence them too. This is about (for the most part) the singing, and no one left can compare to Kelly.