PDA

View Full Version : Optimal Exposure


MarkBarbieri
04-06-2007, 10:11 AM
Want to know the trick to getting the best possible exposure when taking a picture? The histogram is the key.

Your camera probably has lots of different exposure modes - spot, partial, center weighted, evaluative, matrix, etc. For this lesson, don't worry about which mode you use because it doesn't matter. The reason is that we are going to use the histogram as our meter.

Set up your composition and take a picture. Now check the histogram. If you have a line on the far right-hand side of the histogram, your exposure is too high and you need to reduce your exposure. You can do that by shooting in manual and just lowering the shutter speed or aperture, lowering the ISO, or using exposure compensation.

If you look at the histogram and you have room between the rightmost part of the graph and the rightmost edge of the histogram, you want to increase your exposure. The trick is to get the exposure as far to the right as possible without hitting the edge.

Hitting the edge is bad because those pixels are "blown out." They are just plain white. Sometimes you can't avoid it. If the sun is in your picture, it's going to blow out. Specular reflects also tend to blow out. If you can't or won't change your composition or lighting to make them go away, decide what parts you can ignore and let them blow out. Most of the time, however, you should strive to keep everything off of the right edge.

Why try to get close? Your camera records better information on the more exposed (but not over-exposed) pixels than it does on the darker pixels. This is primarily because the signal (the stuff you want) to noise (the grainy, extraneous stuff you don't want) is higher for the more exposed pixels.

Won't that mean that my picture will be too bright? Maybe right out of the camera it will, but you can adjust it back down using your photo editor. When you do so, the picture will be better than it would have been if you'd shot it dimmer in the first place.

What about the left edge? Ideally, you don't want pixels piled up against the left edge either. These represent parts of the picture that are just plain black with no detail. However, these don't hurt the look of a picture as bad as blown out parts do, so if you can't get everything to fit your histogram, err on the side of leaving dark parts rather than bright parts.

When exposing for the right edge, make sure that you use the RGB histogram and not the average luminance histogram. The former shows you a histogram for each of the three sensor colors. The latter averages them together and shows just the average. If you take a picture of a bright red flower, you can easily blow out the red pixels while the average luminance still looks OK. You don't end up with white pixels there, but you do lose detail in the red colors, which is almost as bad.

Some older digital SLRs have only an average luminance histogram, so you don't have a choice. With those, you have to guess or bracket.

extreme8
04-06-2007, 10:44 AM
Now ya done it Mark.
Get ready for the "how do I know the difference between RGB & Average Luminance histogram on my camera" posts;)

Great post. I'm sure many will find it helpful.

ukcatfan
04-06-2007, 11:15 AM
You guys have got me on the true histogram. My K100D only has the average histogram. I believe the only Pentax with a true one is the K10D. I will add one thing for those like me. Mark, you might be able to explain better as I am sure you will know what I am talking about.

My camera just shows the average histogram, but it also can flash the parts of a shot that are considered blown out. It is not as good as the histogram Mark describes, but you can use it to tell if you over did it so you can re-take the shot. I guess this feature falls in the middle.

Kevin

Master Mason
04-06-2007, 11:42 AM
Just average with the XT as well

mabas9395
04-06-2007, 11:46 AM
My rebel XT only has the average histogram, and I know how to adjust my exposure to get my histogram the way I want it. But if I had an RBG histogram and I was shooting a red rose as Mark suggests, and my Red channel was blown out, how would I go about adjusting my exposure? Is there something you can do to make sure the reds aren't blown out while still exposing correctly for the blues and greens? Or do you need to adjust your average exposure so that the hotest channel is exposed correctly and then boost the other channels in post production?

This is good stuff. Might be kind of heavy for a Friday morning though, I need to stop talking about photography and actually get out and take some pictures.

MarkBarbieri
04-06-2007, 12:44 PM
With a quick check, it looks like the K10D, the Rebel XTi, and the Nikon D80 all have an RGB histogram. The K100D, the D50, the D40, D70, and the Rebel XT appear to only have luminance histograms. Given that it costs almost nothing to add, I hope that competition will force it down the ranks for all the manufacturers.

While not a perfect solution, the luminance histogram is still very useful in this area. You just have to give yourself a bit more margin for error. If nothing in the picture is particularly saturated, you're probably OK. If it is, bracket down 1/2 stop just to be safe.

But if I had an RBG histogram and I was shooting a red rose as Mark suggests, and my Red channel was blown out, how would I go about adjusting my exposure? Is there something you can do to make sure the reds aren't blown out while still exposing correctly for the blues and greens? Or do you need to adjust your average exposure so that the hotest channel is exposed correctly and then boost the other channels in post production?

Your exposure is for all color channels. If you adjusted one, it would throw off your color balance. Your goal is to make sure that no color climbs the right edge. So if you are taking a picture with a really bright saturated red, you have to set your exposure to make sure it doesn't get over exposed.

MarkBarbieri
04-06-2007, 12:49 PM
While we are on the subject of histogram variances, I have to say that high end Nikon shooters have it the best. They can set blinkies by color channel and they can show their histogram over the full LCD.

DueyDooDah
04-06-2007, 01:06 PM
Thanks, Mark. Good simple explanation. I'm really glad you touched on the RGB histogram. I have it, but really didn't understand the difference or how to interpret the results. This little tutorial should help me fix those flower and ocean shots I've been missing.

Steve's Girl
04-06-2007, 01:12 PM
I have been reading quite a bit about exposure lately trying to figure out how to get it right. As Mark stated, I have learned that the histogram is absolutely necessary to achieve correct exposure. Fortunately, my camera has an RBG histogram which is a huge help.

I recently read a rather lengthy, technical article about using the different channels. Honestly, most of the technical stuff went right over my head. But the summation has been quite useful - any red or blue channel blowout typically means you need to reduce exposure. I can't remember why that is other than something to do with the dominance of green, blah, blah, blah. In practice, I am finding this to be a very helpful tool.